The Roar
The Roar

13th Man

Roar Pro

Joined December 2014

632

Views

2

Published

142

Comments

Published

Comments

Agree. Replace Bailey in the xi with Shaun Marsh. He is the superior player to Bailey. Give Smith captaincy and we will do better.

If Clarke is fit, drop Bailey for the Cricket World Cup

I think if Marsh or White makes runs today and Smith captains well, even if Clarke is ruled out Bailey could still miss out for Marsh or White.

Bailey's form puts him first in line to be cut for Clarke

They have good batting
there bowling attack is awful
you won’t get anywhere in Aus when two of your quicks Kumar and Shami are medium pace trundlers that bowl 120.
india should pick Yadav, Ishant Sharma and Aaron if they are to be any chance.

Establishing the World Cup pretenders

Cook is way too conservative to be a good captain, doesn’t take any risks, would not risk losing to try and win.
England should sack him and bring back KP , they would do so much better.

What has happened to Alastair Cook?

To be honest, I have no problem with what Warner said. Sledging to Warner in Hindi is kind of stupid and childish, Warner told Rohit to step up, be a man and repeat it to him in a language that Warner knew.

David Warner is not the issue, political correctness is

Heres mine
Warner
Amla
De Villiers (wk)
Smith
Clarke (easy to forget him but odi record speaks for itself)
Du Plessis
Faulkner
Johnson
Starc
Steyn
Morkel

That bowling attack is just ridiculously strong. But no spinner so over rate may be a problem.

It is South Africa's Cricket World Cup to lose

Yeah I really would have marsh in over bailey right now. He looked in superb touch last night in the big bash.
I am still a bit iffy over whether he is a great test player but he is a class limited overs player.

It is South Africa's Cricket World Cup to lose

However you did chase 436 against us once.

It is South Africa's Cricket World Cup to lose

NZ have mcullum as well.

It is South Africa's Cricket World Cup to lose

Dont get too cocky mate.
Didn’t Aus just beat SA 4 1 in an ODI series.
certainly I think you guys will make the final but then we will see another Edgbaston 1999 debacle I hope.

It is South Africa's Cricket World Cup to lose

Bailey really is out of form. The problem is he is the backup captain which means he is unlikely to get dropped for either Marsh or White especially considering that if either came into the squad It would be for Clarke therefore Bailey would be captain.

White over Shaun Marsh for World Cup

Good point. I feel he is the better of the Marsh bros.

White over Shaun Marsh for World Cup

Yeah I would have Marsh at 3, move Watson to 5. Have White at 6.

White over Shaun Marsh for World Cup

I would have gone Behrendorff but selectors dont want to pick to many left armers.

Australia rest Warner, ring the changes and name Steve Smith captain

He is still playing for Scorchers today and White is playing for Stars.
they go to Hobart tommorow.

Australia rest Warner, ring the changes and name Steve Smith captain

Yes Voges is very unlucky, age it seems has counted against him.

Personally I would have White and Marsh in there over Bailey and Maxwell.

White over Shaun Marsh for World Cup

Sorry if this is a really dumb question but How does altitude affect how far a cricket ball flies.

AB de Villiers' record will be broken within 12 months

Starc is a much better bowler than McLenaghan. I think Kiwis have missed a trick not including Matt Henry in there WC squad. Looks a very good bowler, should be in over Kyle Mills I think.

Starc shaping as the dominant Mitchell for the World Cup

Two changes to last nights winning XI for me. Mitch Marsh and Clarke (or Shaun Marsh if Clarke is ruled out) come in and Maxwell and Bailey go out.
On the subject of spinners I think we need one as well but unfortunately we do not have a good enough one in the squad. Doherty and Maxwell are second rate at best.
also Johnson in for Sandhu obviously.

Starc shaping as the dominant Mitchell for the World Cup

Yeah agree. The umps will review every close decision not just a couple an innings. You could lose 5 to 10 overs a day if every single close lbw shout and catch behind is reviewed considering some take a few minutes to be reviewed.
I like the current system, two reviews means players have to think before they review. If its obviously out, off you go. Its not perfect but DRS is the best we have. India need to suck it up and fall in line or not play international cricket. Simple as that.

India could push DRS to where it always should have been

I would go the second option. Marsh and Doherty. Mainly because I would rather see Marsh coming in at 4/60 than Maxwell. Marsh also wouldve kept his head more than Maxwell.
I want to try fit both in but involves dropping Finch or Watson and atm cant do that. Doherty did his job in the middle overs well against England. Marsh probably a better bat and bowler than Maxwell.

Faulkner the finisher steers Australia home

Faulkner will play in WC
He has too.
the other spot is between Maxwell and Marsh and I think Marsh should get that unless selectors don’t want to play Doherty.
Bailey has to go! It severly weakens Aus lineup to have Bailey 5 and Maxwell 6 when guys like White, Voges, S Marsh and M Marsh are all available.

my wc team
1. Finch
2. Warner
3. Watson
4. Smith
5. Clarke/S Marsh
6. M Marsh
7. Haddin
8. Faulkner
9. Johnson
10. Starc
11. Doherty

Faulkner the finisher steers Australia home

My odi side
Gilchrist
M Waugh
Ponting
Jones
Hussey
Bevan
Symonds
Hogg (I know Warnie was better but still)
Johnson
Lillee
McGrath
Lee (12th)

Debating Warne's all-time Australian ODI side

Yes GB Hogg
get him in there, what a legend Hoggy is!

Debating Warne's all-time Australian ODI side

If your 4 for 60 you can send Haddin out first i

Australia should use Maxwell as sole spinner

close