The Roar
The Roar

Andy F

Roar Rookie

Joined April 2019

0

Views

0

Published

1.1k

Comments

Published

Comments

Andy F hasn't published any posts yet

Worst game management I’ve seen in a GF. Up by 16. In the Panther’s 22 and you take a high risk play that lets the pressure off. Someone had to be the adult in the room. I guess the Broncs were sticking with what got them the lead but sheesh Reynolds should’ve taken charge and forced a repeat set.

Also one criticism, either league are serious about high shots, crusher tackles and HIA’s. In origin and finals, particularly GF’s they let a lot go. I understand why but really? Does anyone believe the player welfare claptrap anymore? The policies are just a future litigation shield and if you keep making exceptions the shield just won’t work.

Cleary's immortal display inspires Panthers to pull off record comeback win for three-peat and break Broncos hearts

I was just gobsmacked by the forward pass call at the end of the first 1/2 to deny a try. I watched it 3 or 4 times an I’ve got no idea how it was called forward or at the very least not referred. I feel certain had it been referred it would not have been called forward.

‘Robbed’: Fiji seal dramatic, controversial win over Georgia to hammer another nail into the Wallabies' coffin

Honestly, this side could lose to Portugal.

'Fall guy': Eddie doubles down on future, makes three changes as Wallabies sweat on RWC miracle

Dear Eddie, if you’re going to comment why the Botticelli pseudonym?

SPIRO ZAVOS: My message to Hamish McLennan and Eddie Jones: 'In the name of God, go'

Not as experienced as the new crop who have the lonely scalp of traditional rivals Georgia under their belt.

Eddie Jones should be celebrated not booed: Why the worst thing RA could do is sack the Wallabies coach

Wait. So after writing fan puff pieces on EJ in the WC lead up you give him some curry in an article yesterday. You are somewhat pilloried for your hypocrisy. So today you answer with an article supporting EJ and complimenting his vision for change? Not sure I see your point unless of course you’re just stirring up controversy.
Do you as an author actually stand for anything or do you just want to get eyes on your words. Do you really believe what you’ve written?

Eddie Jones should be celebrated not booed: Why the worst thing RA could do is sack the Wallabies coach

Meh. Your statement that players lost confidence due to the media is pure speculation. The truth is EJ is not a good coach and had no plan B. His selections were diabolical and game plan pretty much non-existent. His recent coaching record with Australia and England is terrible.

Eddie Jones should be celebrated not booed: Why the worst thing RA could do is sack the Wallabies coach

EJ “I take full responsibility.”

Wow! Gee thanks Eddie. How noble of you.

Is there any reason on earth why you felt it necessary to make this comment?

You made crazy selections. You brought in a sub par yes men assistant coaching team.

You chose the strategy and game plan (assuming there was one).

Of course you are responsible you clown. If you worked for any organisation with standards you’d be immediately sacked. Your record is appalling. As is the record of the board and CEO of RA (including many years of senior management negligence). Sure there’ll be some scapegoats but will the structural change need ever take place? I doubt it.

'Complete dismantling': Eddie apologises for World Cup debacle, Hoops calls out moment that summed it up

Spot on. Jones took a giant long odds gamble with no risk to himself. To say the CEO and board of RA have egg on their face is one huge understatement.

'Complete dismantling': Eddie apologises for World Cup debacle, Hoops calls out moment that summed it up

Um yes it is the players fault. The coach, selections, game plan etc are also at fault but it is the players fault as well.

'Complete dismantling': Eddie apologises for World Cup debacle, Hoops calls out moment that summed it up

They’ll probably stay on the Randwick merry go round so they’ll ask Cheika back. ????????

'Complete dismantling': Eddie apologises for World Cup debacle, Hoops calls out moment that summed it up

Deans – agree
Rennie – agree
Castle – you’re having a laugh. She was a complete disaster.

'Bloody disappointed: Wallabies OUT of World Cup as nation to miss finals for first time, Eddie fights for survival

Was this one of the journos singing Eddie’s praises. I can’t stand EJ and I think RA is run by myopic box tickers but I reserve my true hatred for hypocrites.

'Bloody disappointed: Wallabies OUT of World Cup as nation to miss finals for first time, Eddie fights for survival

I don’t really have respect for commentators who are calling out EJ’s madness now. Frankly I respect guys like Campo who called it out weeks ago.
Australian Rugby requires a complete top down clean out. Won’t happen though.

'Complete dismantling': Eddie apologises for World Cup debacle, Hoops calls out moment that summed it up

Von Moltke said “no plan survives contact with the enemy.”
Or as mike Tyson put it “everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face”.

No doubt EJ had a bold and decisive plan. It has been an abject failure so far. IMHO he has elevated players above their capacity at this stage.

No doubt EJ wants to win but his hubris has put the wallabies at risk of second tier status. His confidence in his own ability is misplaced. There just isn’t a plan B. That’s bad leadership.

'Spooked': Wallabies star reacts to Mitchell meltdown, as Campo claims youngsters 'don't understand importance' of WC

What about the leg lift on Smith that landed him on his head?

Klein should be declined chance to referee Grand Final again after blatant clangers in Storm-Roosters cliffhanger

I guess everyone will call me a whinger but the refereeing? Is it just me?

'Gutted': Cheika's Pumas steal dramatic win to confirm Eddie's worst Wallabies fears

Possibly in the women’s game. He has the hair for it.

Blues player ratings: Time for legend to call it quits, Luai no good without Cleary, why was Cam Murray barely used?

😂 😂

Blues player ratings: Time for legend to call it quits, Luai no good without Cleary, why was Cam Murray barely used?

I thought Luai was horrible. Bad kicks, slow thinking. Great club player hasn’t done well in origin this year. Frankly I find his tough guy attitude laughable.

Blues player ratings: Time for legend to call it quits, Luai no good without Cleary, why was Cam Murray barely used?

Cricket’ll be there for you (like it’s been there before)

ANALYSIS: Slater's smarts win the day as Blues out-thought and out-fought by Maroons

Luai was awful. Cook played out of position was all at sea. NSW just useless. Peculiar 1st 1/2 try decisions. Not a very exciting game to watch. Be surprised if game 3 outrates Friends reruns.

ANALYSIS: Slater's smarts win the day as Blues out-thought and out-fought by Maroons

Can’t agree here. Sure played for the AB’s but childhood (13 years) in Darwin, mum played for Australia, wants to do it. Ticks all the boxes for me. You can play for 2 countries and still be a great and loyal person.

COMMENT: 'Australia is a tier-two nation' - Eddie must pick former All Blacks star for 'smash and grab' World Cup

There are only 2 vital questions that should be asked in relation to World Cup selection:
1. Is the player eligible?
2. Is the player in the top 2 of all the eligible players in his chosen position?
If the answer is yes to both then pick the guy. Everything else is white noise.

COMMENT: 'Australia is a tier-two nation' - Eddie must pick former All Blacks star for 'smash and grab' World Cup

Whenever a significant change to our constitution is mooted by referendum and someone says “trust me – it’ll be ok”, I get a shiver down my spine.

Rugby News: Ex-PM says RA has succumbed to 'moral blackmail' after 'regrettable' Voice stance revealed

close