The Roar
The Roar

Eddie from Elwood

Roar Rookie

Joined March 2019

0

Views

0

Published

574

Comments

Published

Comments

Eddie from Elwood hasn't published any posts yet

Maybe if we pinched Leppa and Fly from you the hate may return………God I hope you hate us soon Pete…….but I don’t think they’re coming.

Damien Hardwick: A Richmond man that may never coach again

A quote from Stan Grant about being a journalist –

“Too often, we are the poison in the bloodstream of our society.”

Sometimes there are times in my job where I have or should let things go.

Damien Hardwick's 'fatal mistake': Emotional Tigers coach explains role Last Dance doco played in shock exit

The intent was for him to pole axe Ol’ Sniffy, did he intend to hit in the head…..I don’t think so, but he was near horizontal to the ground…pretty sure he intended to hurt him a lot.

AFL needs urgent adjustment to concussion sanctions and player punishments

Wow……..splitter!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Am I? You have corrected, on what, I’m not sure, so please tell me this story of correction?

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

???? Correct me on what?

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

You’re of your rocker Don, I mentioned Luke Jackson as a trade Freo had made. That was it, the rest is your inane ramblings and petulant get backs. I read what you said I don’t even think you know what you said. You demand me answer to you, yet ignore what I have written. Thanks but, no thanks, a Brickhill is more engaging than you Don.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

At no stage did I say they were no good, what are you on about? Mate go back a read, try comprehending it too it might help you get a grip on things.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Not sure what you’re on about, I have agreed with you to a point and offered a counter, the same counter I’ve mentioned continuously through the thread, which you have ignored or passed off as non information, which it isn’t if you don’t ignore what I saying. Now you’re back to a bunch of players names again.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

As I replied, there aren’t as many as Freo with runs on the board as the list profile are years apart. Freo on the up Richmond on the other side, hence topping up…..was pretty easy to see, I’ve been focused and breathing from the beginning…..have you?

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Wha? I have never been angry or on a tangent…..maybe read the post from the beginning, haven’t waivered at all.
My new point is your petulance which you frequently stoop to when you are challenged. Tey humility, it’s far more becoming.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Keep ignoring the point to get your leg up Don…….as I said petulant best.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Where was that challenge issued? You mentioned a bunch a names and I did, skeletal, has beens, whatever, as I said, to say Richmond don’t develop their own players is a ridiculous notion, as they have and continue too, they just currently don’t have the crop Freo have as the lists are in different spots, this has been my argument the whole time time, which you wanted to turn into a p15sing contest……at your petulant best!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Richmond does not develop its youth. If you look at Freo’s list and suggest its strength does not come from its developed youth, you are looking at someone else’s list not Freo’s.
I gave you many names of youth Richmond have developed, they are just older as Richmond’s list is in a different generation to Freo. The 5 new kids Richmond have are just the start of the new generation. To say that Richmond have only built a team from trades is just a ridiculous notion and ignores the last 10 years or more.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Multiple Premiership winning scraps!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

I’m well aware some of them are not on the list……tells you something right there about Freo’s trading.
It’s funny how much your telling me I don’t know about Freo’s list, when it all started with me telling you you were off on your RCD/Hopper call!
Like I said, talk to me in 5 or so years and we’ll see what Freo has achieved and how they are approaching the list management…..I bet they are topping up too!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

So you’re telling me that Richmond have no home grown stars in the team?
And of the 5 youngsters, three have played multiple games and done well. Yes, I only mentioned Jackson, I left out Lobb, Aish, Hogan, Wilson and the rest. Both teams are a different point in list management, so in 5 or so years, when they’re topping up you might get it.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Different positions on the scale Don, Freo coming up, Tigers on the other side of the peak. When Freo are in the same place in 5 or so years, let’s see how many flags and how they work on their list to make a comparison……my bet is they’re doing the same thing…..topping up! All clubs do it, you know it, Lobb, Acres, Hogan, O’Meara, Clarke, Jackson. And of your list of developed players……Grimes, Vlastuin, Broad, Macintosh, Rioli, Short, Baker, Bolton, Cotchin, Riewoldt, Martin and they’re the ones still playing.
Come on man, forget the barbs and bait.

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

5 picks inside the top 30 2021, prior to that a large list of mature agers and rookie pick developed. List development requires both trades and picks.
Luke Jackson say hi ???? by the way!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

Why do you think that is?

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

RCD was a passenger, no ticker and incapable of doing the hard yards, Hopper certainly isn’t that!

2023 Best 23s: Does influx of stars mean a brutal call for Trent Cotchin at Tigerland?

And the infighting, not just off the field. Lever and May at each other all night, in fact Lever at it with many of his team mates. Then finishes up with a selfish act just after his team mates tried to get back into it.

AFL Finals Focus: Here's how the Lions inflicted an upset for the ages... and why an eye gouge could cost them everything

All round great person and player, go well Lambo!

'Future Kane ends up with a hip replacement': Tigers flag hero opens up on health battle

The media want Dusty to be forced to comment so they can ask the question they really want the answered to………Are you going to be at Richmond next year

AFL News: Dustin Martin grope video surfaces, Lions lock in rare finals debutant

That’s pretty much how I see it.

BRETT GEEVES: The MRP, with its inconsistencies and misuse of precedents, is an enormous laugh

close