The Roar
The Roar

TheFireFighterOfAntarctica

Roar Rookie

Joined September 2020

7.9k

Views

2

Published

21

Comments

Published

Comments

“Pots?” So the top 3 are POT 1. 4,5,6 are POT 2. 7,8,9 are POT 3, etc etc.
So you want the top side after Round 17 to play a team that’s 16th, 17th or last. And a team in 13th, 14th or 15th……..

Really?

The AFL fixture changes that will make the game fairer

You asked how much broadcasters are prepared to pay for meaningless games – you were referring to the bottom 6 Cup.
Right now, they’re paying big bucks.
This 17-5 system removes the top 6 from the bottom 6. That’s what I call meaningless!

The AFL fixture changes that will make the game fairer

Gilberto,
In an ideal world, it would be great if the bottom six teams ended their season after Round 17. But Broadcast Rights and Sponsorship dictates Professional sport now.

The AFL fixture changes that will make the game fairer

In a perfect world, each region/city should have their own spotlight.

But it’s too simplistic to remove, (as an example), The All-Star Mile and Australian Cup to the spring, in exchange for The Everest and The Golden Eagle to the Autumn. Sure, it would definitely beef up their respected carnivals – But it will never happen!!!!!

Sometimes less is more - Caulfield Cup and The Everest can't be staged on the same day

“SYDNEY GIANTS”

What's in a name? Should AFL's newest clubs make a change?

“……Clarkson in a ‘starring’ role and Fagan as a silent but present participant, makes their positions at the helm of those clubs untenable…..”

Fagan has denied being in the room!!!

Geewhiz!! Big call to run a story like this, so early!!

Basically, all we heard today and tonight was; “If this is true, then……”

North Melbourne and Brisbane must sack Clarkson and Fagan after Hawthorn racism revelations

The system you have suggested is called the 17-5. It was mooted at AFL house back in 2010.
12 years later, and still no change.
What a shame!!!

How to create a fairer AFL home and away season for all

All sports love a ‘Cinderella Story”.
One day, a team will win from 8th spot. It might happen once in every 30 years. But isn’t that what fans want? HOPE!!!!

It’s time for the NRL to ditch the top eight

Is there money in the Olympics’ budget for a retractable roof at Suncorp?

Magic Round just became aquatic round: Why you should never play eight NRL games at the same venue

There’s some comments on here about the lack of crowds due to public transport.

Hypothetical here: (…..and it’s a big one!!!!!)

If ANZ was knocked down and they built a stadium over or under Central Station, would the crowds improve dramatically?
(Hypothetically, the federal Government is throwing in $5 billion– lol)

Why are we so obsessed with crowds in rugby league?

Rob9,
Good article.
The name of the new team seems to be an issue with you, due to the location of Redcliffe.

Just an idea – We have the:
“Golden State Warriors” from California.

What about the:
“Sunshine State Dolphins” from Queensland?

An alternate and simple pathway to 18 teams that will work

At the start of each season the NRL will guarantee at least one Sydney team in the Grand Final.
…………….This is a terrible idea!!

Important Issues In Growing the Game –
1: Expansion
2: Draft
3: More “Free to Air” games
.
47: Conferences

Conference system reportedly back on the NRL's radar

As a Melbournian, I hope to have another Melbourne team in the NRL by 2031.

A local kid will come through sooner, rather than later, and inspire a new generation.

Patience is needed.

Where are all the Victorians in the NRL?

The “kick in” after a behind:
The ‘Clock’ doesn’t start when the fullback kicks it in. It starts at the next clear possession.
So if the fullback kicks to a pack on a flank and a mark is taken, the clock starts.
If the ball spills and a player picks it up and is clear possession, the clock starts.
If the player picks it up but is immediately tackled, the clock doesn’t start.
And the field umpires don’t have to worry about all of the above.
The umpire sitting in the stands adjudicates when to stop, start and reset.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

Thanks for the comments, Brian.
Everything you stated, is happening now, without a clock.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

Seymorebutts thanks for your comments. Unfortunately, the game has evolved to the entertainment industry. Which is part of the problem.
Cats vs Tigers last Friday was a game everybody was looking forward to. It’s a pity the Cats chose to go slow and give us a fizzer.

Richmond’s style of play is what we’re after as a benchmark.
Earlier in the year, at Adelaide Oval, we witnessed arguably, the best game in 10 years, when Port got up against the Tiggers. The ball was pinging around like a pinball, as both sides moved the ball quickly and attacked.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

X1, No. Maybe read the article again, Mate!

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

If you’re a basketball fan but still trying to get your head around this concept; Think of the 50 metre arc line as the basketball ring.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

XI, I suggest you read the article again. This is not an inside 50 clock.
The proposal is; you have (eg:) 30 seconds to get the ball into your forward 50 arc.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

DTM,
You are correct with your assumption.

Once you gain clear control of the ball, you have 24/30/36 seconds to get the ball into your 50 arc.
Once you’re in your arc, you can take as long as you like. Most likely, you’re shooting at goal by that stage.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

If you like footy from the 1990’s, then this is the rule for you.

How an old NBA rule could boost AFL scoring rates

close