Wallaby disgrace! Money comes before the jersey
By Spiro Zavos, 23 Sep 2009 Spiro Zavos is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- robbie deans, Rugby Union, Tri Nations, wallabies
147 Have your say
Related coverage

The Australian Wallabies during the team training session in Brisbane, Friday, July 4, 2008. AAP Image/Dave Hunt
At 6.45am on Tuesday, my phone rang. It was Geoff Mould and he was as mad as hell about the demand by some senior Wallabies for $2,500 to play a trial match before the overseas tour.
Mould is a rugby guru.
He coached and selected the 1978 Australian Schoolboys side which is, arguably, the best rugby side produced in Australia. He spotted the Ella brothers at Matraville High, and had a lot to do with their development as master players and thinkers about the game.
Now he was incensed.
“Sorry to ring you so early,” he told me. “I can’t believe it, this story in the Herald about the players refusing to play a trial match unless they are paid $2,500. This mob of poofters couldn’t beat their aunt fanny even if she was playing in a wheelchair. Just play the game, and those who refuse to play unless they are paid, can miss out on the tour!”
According to Tony Dempsey, the chief executive of the Rugby Union Players Association, the players trade union, they were happy to play for nothing: “If it was just an internal trial to select the touring team at North Sydney Oval, we wouldn’t expect to be paid.”
But what RUPA objected to, according to Dempsey, was playing a high profile match put on by the NSWRU as part of their season schedule. The Australian reported that the amount of money RUPA wanted for this high profile match was around $7,500.
This figure is much higher than the figure quoted by Greg Growden in the SMH, in his story of the episode.
He reported that RUPA was approached by some senior Wallabies about the match and the demand of $2,500 a player to play in it was made on the ARU by RUPA.
According to Growden, it was the ARU, not the NSWRU, that decided not to go ahead with the match. Growden also reported that the dispute had been simmering for some time before the ARU decided to pull the plug on the idea.
This version of the affair fits what I knew, or was being told, over the past month or so about the possibility of the game.
It may be that both versions are correct and that the NSWRU tried unsuccessfully to get its Wallabies-Australian Barbarians trial game up, and that the ARU also failed to get its Possibles-Probables trial up too.
It is clear that that if a rampant demand for money had not been made by RUPA, there would have been a trial match, probably under the auspices of the ARU, which has run similar matches many times in the past.
There is a back story to all of this.
When News Ltd made its offer to support a SANZAR Super Rugby tournament and a Tri-Nations tournament on Pay TV, Channel 9 (with the ruthless Kerry Packer in charge) tried to destroy the concept by creating a rebel rugby organisation.
The chief organisers among the players for the rebels were Sean Fitzpatrick, Francois Pienaar and Phil Kearns, the then captains of the All Blacks, the Springboks and the Wallabies.
The Australian part of this troika played hard ball to get its way, to the extent of banning John Eales from meetings between the players and dismissing Eales as ‘old jellyback’ for his refusal to sell out the Wallaby jersey to Packer.
When a settlement was made between the rebel players and the ARU, the union was really hammered in the agreement. John O’Neill came on board as CEO of the ARU after other executives found that they could run rugby in Australia when most of the money coming in went out to the players.
RUPA, which was bankrolled by the ARU, has fought O’Neill persistently and viciously as he tried to get a more equitable dispersal of the News Ltd monies to promote and grow rugby in Australia.
This latest disgrace is part of the continuing battle, it seems to me, between RUPA and O’Neill, a battle in which, again in my opinion, RUPA has invariably been in the wrong.
The irony in all of this is that the Australian players this season have not justified the lavish payments being made to them.
There were no Australian Super 14 sides in the finals. And the Wallabies have had a poor year which ended in the All Blacks scoring their fifth largest victory since 1903 over them.
Not long after I took Mould’s phone call, I exchanged some pleasantries with a neighbour, Patrick, who lives across the street. “Weren’t the Wallabies terrible on Saturday,” he called out to me. “I can’t bear to watch them any more.”
When Patrick said that, the thought came to me that right now the Wallabies should be paying us money to watch them, not the other way around.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- robbie deans, Rugby Union, Tri Nations, wallabies

megatron said | September 23rd 2009 @ 1:32am | Report comment
Disgrace. Seems like rugby has succumbed to the modern sportsman and all the greed that comes with it.
ohtani's jacket said | September 23rd 2009 @ 1:36am | Report comment
Whatever the truth of this matter, it’s a kick in the balls for Wallaby supporters. They ought to rectify this situation immediately.
MM said | September 23rd 2009 @ 1:58am | Report comment
Spiro has outlined the facts regarding their actual play, losses, etc.
Isn’t that where the focus lies? With the players and coaching staff.
Whatever the truth is, what did they really want to accomplish if it pulled off? Certainly not changing history – perhaps just adding a statement in their own minds….
ohtani's jacket said | September 23rd 2009 @ 2:07am | Report comment
I’m not sure if I follow you exactly, but if I were a Wallaby supporter, I’d want to see a trial (even if it’s not called that), and I’d want to see the players take this upcoming tour deadly seriously.
After 2005, all we heard out of Australia was how they were getting better and ever closer to winning back the Bledisloe. Well, now they’re back where they were in 2005. The last four years have been a waste of just about everyone’s time and energy.
mother teresa said | September 23rd 2009 @ 8:29am | Report comment
jack nicholson said you cant handle the truth otherwise tell it as it is son
Matt0931 said | September 23rd 2009 @ 3:41am | Report comment
I don’t think we have been given the whole story here.
From what I understand this ‘trial’ match was going to be a Wallabies A V Australian Barbarians match and was not supposed to be a commercial venture and the wallabies were going to play for nothing originally. It was only when the news came out that the game was making up part of the NSWRU’s season schedule and that some of the proceeds may have gone to the NSWRU that RUPA asked for some proceeds if the game was in fact going to be a commercial venture.
Also, the $2500 they asked for is the match day payment made to Australia A players anyway. The $7500 payment mentioned in the story is the fee players received for playing in the past Australia Wallabies v barbarians match.
I do think the ARU needs to get tougher with RUPA and work to reduce player contracts but I don’t think this should be done through match day fees. Match day fees are in place to keep a level playing fields otherwise the ARU would be free to make the players play as many games as the ARU felt without paying them any extra for playing extra games.
Now ask yourself this – If your boss asked you to work for nothing on a sunday when you knew he would be making a tidy sum from the day would you want to work?
Of course you wouldn’t.
Chris said | September 23rd 2009 @ 7:40am | Report comment
My job is officially Monday – Friday, but I regularly work weekends, late nights … but I don’t get paid extra. I do it because I’m passionate about my job. Imagine the passion you’d have if you could play the sport you love for your country?
I am very disappointed with the recent Wallabies performances, but I feel the majority of the players would not be privy to all the discussions between the RUPA and the ARU. I think they have now been a hung out to dry for a decision that they had little influence over. They are in a tough spot, they feel they are putting in 100% on the training paddock but the results aren’t coming… and then fans like me are putting the boot in. It would be frustrating.
For the sake of the game, the ARU and the RUPA need to put their differences aside and make sure this game proceeds. Any profits from the game should be given to developed grassroots rugby and a portion given to charity.
Bay35Pablo said | September 23rd 2009 @ 8:59am | Report comment
Chris, would you front up for that extra time if it involved getting tackled by a 120kg Kiwi/Bok every minute?
Having said that, the performance on saturday night was the equivalent of the office worker surfing the web and updating his facebook page during office hours …
Vented Relief said | September 23rd 2009 @ 10:13am | Report comment
…..and blogging on The Roar…..
Ben J said | September 23rd 2009 @ 3:58pm | Report comment
Selling Wallaby tickets is not a job Chris
But yes I agree, there is a lack of seriousness about these Wallabies. Too cushy at the moment?
avsfan said | September 23rd 2009 @ 10:05am | Report comment
Mate, I think you’re splitting hairs here. The match is supposed to be a trial for places on the NH tour. Players should be crawling across cut glass for an opportunity to play in this match, not quibbling over what is for them small change, but for the average punter a decent load of cash. No wonder the Wannabees are so woeful, if this is their mindset.
Skip said | September 23rd 2009 @ 10:08am | Report comment
Chris,
Most people who get paid above the award to work overtime for no compensation and the majority on them would be on a fraction of what these prima donna’s are getting paid. It is how most people feed there families and keep thier Jobs.
Nashi said | September 23rd 2009 @ 12:28pm | Report comment
“Match day fees are in place to keep a level playing fields otherwise the ARU would be free to make the players play as many games as the ARU felt without paying them any extra for playing extra games.”
Aren’t the players restricted to 32 games per season, and if so doesn’t that make your point invalid?
AndyS said | September 23rd 2009 @ 4:08pm | Report comment
So if they designated the mid year Tests as “selection” matches for the TriNations, and any Aus A matches as “trials” for the Wallabies? In most instances that is exactly what they are; you have only to read back over comments here to see the speculation around what those matches meant. So there wouldn’t be any chance that the ARU would be tempted to call them selection friendlies on a play-or-no-selection basis?
As for those working weekends for high pay, that’s fine, been there. Mind you, my boss also wasn’t taking the money he saved and using it to train my replacement, or requiring me to help said youngster learn. I also noticed a funny thing over the years…those that did it tended to get bypassed, because they were more valuable in that position working for nothing than they would be in a better/higher paid position. There is a limit to the analogy between us and an elite sportsman. Think of it this way perhaps – you work, but one bad sickie and you may well not work in this country again except on much less money. You’d be how keen to take unreimbursed risks with your health?
MM said | September 23rd 2009 @ 3:52am | Report comment
Matt,
Certainly what you’ve said makes the most sense and it’s a pity good intentions aren’t kept at the fore and more of the big truth behind this unveiled.
johnyfairplay2006 said | September 23rd 2009 @ 4:19am | Report comment
maybe the wallabies supporters should wear armbands next game – what a sorry bunch they are, these wallabies. you talk about the boks bringing the game into disrepute.
MM said | September 23rd 2009 @ 5:24am | Report comment
Johnyfair,
There are always good laughs at some remarks – and definitely – yours fell into that category. Armbands saying what?
It’s sore on the fans who are let down, and maybe this is unfair of me, but we can’t only support our teams when they’re riding the crest of the wave. Every nation’s team endures a cyclical process which I’d like to believe is part of the problem – not the entire problem.
It’s hard to believe that the players go onto the field to lose the game albeit it looks pretty much like that at times. Personally, I think the younger players need a bit of de-throning regarding their attitude – the younger players still have to prove themselves and it’s perhaps their attitude both whilst playing and certainly their fans, they need to reconsider for starters…
CraigB said | September 23rd 2009 @ 7:58am | Report comment
how about – Justice 4 Us!!!!
Rusty said | September 23rd 2009 @ 1:36pm | Report comment
how about “Men for Gold” or “Gold 4 Us”
warrenexpatinnz said | September 23rd 2009 @ 5:17am | Report comment
A team in the NZ NPC competiton called the Bay of Plenty Steamers through financial issues have made severe cuts last season and this season where they have to do things like;
Wash their own jumpers
Stay in two star or less accomadtion
Romm with two or more players
Cook their own meals
This year their coach was even sacked at the start of the season yet they reached the top four of the competition last year and are currently sitting third which in the scheme of things is pretty bloody good.
I know this draws a long bow but the Wallabies, like a lot of International sides receive the best of a lot of things and this may have contributed to their seemingly lack of hardness and respect for where they actually sit on the worlds pecking order.
Time for the ARU to reduce the perks they are not signed to a contract on for these players as a good dose of reality will go a long way to make some difference in their present attitude.
Cheers
avsfan said | September 23rd 2009 @ 11:04am | Report comment
Too true warren. the story of Brian Lochore billeting the AB’s with farming folk before the 87 WC to remind them of their roots and who they wore the jersey for was a master stroke. Compare that with the holiday in Corsica before the 07 debacle.
QC said | September 23rd 2009 @ 1:28pm | Report comment
Yes your right Warren however it’s not by choice that they do this. The Bay are the beneficiaries of New Zealand rugby and to be honest should be one of the first unions to be dropped come culling. While their results are very good financially they are a mess. Tew has said it’s going to take alot more than results to keep teams in the top flight. The Bay has been bailed out time and time again and this year is no different. I’d say other unions who have had to battle to get into the red would literally be seeing red should the Bay be taking it easy in nice hotels and dining out.
The bay is a financial mess and they are one of the reasons why the competition is seen to be not sustainable, how could it when they’re holding their hand out every season for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Manawatu and Taranaki two of the smallest unions in the country yet two very sound unions financially who have fought hard to maintain the integrity of their provinces and unions yet they will be two unions surely in the firing line.
Maybe RUPA and the ARU might want to spend a few days with these unions to see what it means to play with passion and pride in the jersey oppossed to playing for cash.
Tahriffc said | September 23rd 2009 @ 5:58am | Report comment
from what I have read this morning the player request was reasonable – if it going to be set up as a commercial venture – then pay them (25% of normal)
If its not a commercial venture – play for free
seems reasonable
johnyfairplay2006 said | September 23rd 2009 @ 5:59am | Report comment
@MM
agreed MM, but i could not help myself having a dig at spiro after his bok-baiting this season and then his triumphalism last week. i posted only one comment last week – “one swallow a summer doesn’t make.”
as for the wallabies – stick with your team, sport wax and wane. before we know it, the boks will be at the bottom and demand more dough. you should see the horsetrading in our provincial set-up, takes the gloss off the game a bit, but then again it’s how they make a living.
now what would the armbands say? “value4fans” maybe?
MM said | September 23rd 2009 @ 7:12am | Report comment
You’re right Johnyfair,
Spiro knows how to stir – but he’s renowned for striking up a controversy, sitting back and watching the responses – a journalistic attribute – not wise to take too seriously.
Who’s my team do you think?
No doubt the Springboks will see the end of their era – so what? There’ll be another triumphant era again, but it’ll be a while I’d think because currently depth is lacked on the bench because of their quota system, and key players appear to be approaching the end of their rugby careers. Just my take which may be right out.
Armbands: “Value4fans”, “Fairness4fans”, and maybe, “Fans-on-strike”.
If one watches the body language and various, yes – the young Wallabies need to pay attention to giving their fans what they deserve rather than embracing ego-centric attitudes (only some – but it impacts on their play nonetheless).
Maaxy said | September 23rd 2009 @ 6:09am | Report comment
Agreed Tahriffic – it is supposed to be professional rugby these days. The game in Japan is purely about making money as was the barbarians game with the headline “SBW” The timing of all this ,if it has been simmering for some time, is interesting. Not a bad time for an employer to deflect poor media from the test series in a different direction. If Deans want this trial he can organise it anytime he likes at any training venue he wants – the players have said no problem. If the trial is about making money then why are the players the only ones being charitable – they have said they will play the trial for free – you always need to look deeper on these things eg read the Australian and not just the SMH to get a fuller picture
mother teresa said | September 23rd 2009 @ 8:23am | Report comment
where oh where have all the leaders gone
tifosi said | September 23rd 2009 @ 6:48am | Report comment
The days of sport not being about money passed away a long time ago. Like it or not move into the 21st century.
Campbell Watts said | September 23rd 2009 @ 11:15am | Report comment
And that attitude is precisely why the Wallabies keep losing – No heart, no passion!!!
They are a bunch of pampered soft cocks, more worried about their hairstyles and looking good than rolling up their sleves and getting stuck in.
Pathetic!!!