Many questions to be answered this summer

Roar Rookie

By Fred Magee, 26 Nov 2009 Fred Magee is a Roar Rookie

Tagged:: Andrew Hilditch, Australian Cricket, Brett Lee, Cricket, Michael Clarke, Michael Hussey, Shane Watson, Stuart Clark, Test cricket, West Indies cricket

Related coverage

Australia's Michael Clarke in action - AAP Image/Tony Phillips

On the morning of the start of another Australian summer of cricket, I believe this could be one of the most fascinating of recent times. This is despite of the wide held perceptions of the low quality of the two touring sides.

The reason for my excitement is that there are a number of questions that need to be answered.

1. Will Michael Hussey last the summer?
My view is that if he scores anything less than 300 runs in the West Indies series, he should be dropped for the Pakistan series. It’s that simple.

2. Will Shane Watson transform himself as an opener?
The Australian selectors obviously feel that Shane Watson is an opener, but does he? If he is to continue as an opener he must convert his starts into big hundreds. If not, his place in the side may be dependent on the answer to the question above.

3. Was extending Andrew Hilditch’s tenure a mistake?
This has all the hallmarks of the decision St George Illawarra made to extend Nathan Brown’s contract prior to sacking him for Wayne Bennett. For the sake of Australian Cricket, I hope I am proven wrong.

4. How many spinners will Australia play this summer?
Logic dictates that Hauritz and Krejza should be the two that play Test cricket this summer, but then again, Hilditch did get his contract extended. So your guess is as good as mine.

5. Is this the right bowling attack to consistently take twenty wickets?
That sound you hear is me dragging my soapbox out again to bleat about the fact that the bowling attack needs to be able to take twenty wickets on a consistent basis. The current attack (bar Stuart Clark) have been given a shot at redemption. Let’s hope that they take it.

6. Are the tourists as bad as everyone thinks?
I won’t be putting my hard-earned on them to win the series but expect some brilliance from the likes of Chanderpaul, Sarwan, Mohammed Yousuf and Shahid Afridi. I still hope Younis Khan boards the flight to Melbourne.

7. Is it the end for Brett Lee and Stuart Clark?
Unless the incumbents are injured, it pains me to say that both Lee and Clark have played their last Test matches for Australia. Lee will join Andrew Flintoff as a short form specialist. The fact the NSW will benefit in having Clark available for the majority of the season is the only positive of his sacking.

8. Is Michael Clarke really planning a Captaincy coup?
During his period of convalescence, Michael Clarke has been seen at the Melbourne Cup and spending time with Tiger. If you believe the papers over the last few weeks, he also went to Fiji for a leadership course.

9. Will the 20/20 Big Bash be the highlight of the summer?
NSW’s win in the Champions Trophy and the inclusion of overseas players should make the Big Bash one of the highlights of the summer. There will be many that hope that this expectation extends to the speed dating in the stands as well.

10. Will Cricket Australia (CA) try innovative things to bring the crowds in this summer?
Well, reduce the prices for a start. $73 for a concourse seat for the Test and $85 for the ODI at the SCG is just taking the proverbial. At this rate, you will need to take a second mortgage out for next year’s Ashes series!

Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.

The Crowd Says (20) | Page 1 of Comments

Freud of Football said | November 26th 2009 @ 5:19am | Report comment

Yes, No, No, 2, No, No, Yes, No, No, No

Reply
Brett McKay said | November 26th 2009 @ 7:26am | Report comment

Hi Fred, great to see you back in these circles. Some good questions here, I might try and add a little more detail than Freud:

1. Huss: probably, I think the Indian series and the break now will help him. 2. Watson: I doubt it. I think he’ll be at 5 or 6 before summer’s end (which possibly contradicts my answer to 1). 3. Hilditch? Hmmm, maybe. Time will tell. 4. At least one spinner, and probably the two you’ve mentioned. Right now, I can’t think of a third banging down the door, and Krezja’a not exactly doing that anyway. 5. 20 wickets? Well, they’ve done it before, so they can do it again.

6. The Windies probably aren’t as bad as is being made out, no. 7. Lee, yes I think so; Clark, maybe not. 8. I’d be surprised if Clarke is planning a coup. 9. Big Bash, not sure about being THE highlight, but there would be big expectations. A Friday night FTA showing would help and 10. Maybe not for the Windies series, but if the crowds are way down, they might need to do something for the Pakistan series. I don’t know they’ll change too much though, becuase they know next year is bascically a guaranteed sell-out. (btw, my tickets for Day1 in Sydney were the same as last year).

For the Freud-summary, that’s: Yes, No, Maybe, 1-2, Yes, No, Yes and No, Doubtful, Probably not, and Probably not again…

Reply
Fred Magee said | November 26th 2009 @ 8:13am | Report comment

Gents, thanks for your thoughts – both in detail and in summary. I think there will be a lot to come out of this summer and that it will not be the disappointment that many think it will be – if for nothing else than the fact that the Australian side is still a work in progress and I dont think they have it quite right yet.

Some of these questions were done with my tongue in my cheek…but one comment I would like to add; I dont think that Michael Clarke is making a push for the captaincy but there has been so much noise around the issue over the last few weeks, you would think that Ricky Ponting and Malcolm Turnbull were in the same boat!

Brett, good to be back…has been a busy month but now it is cricket season, I have returned.

Reply
draexem said | November 26th 2009 @ 8:51am | Report comment

It’s hardly a fascinating summer of cricket. Better words to describe it are ‘farce’ or ‘bore’.

1- Not really a fascinating question because everybody knows what the answer should be, this question just brings up frustration at the selectors. Hussey should have played his last test in the ASHES series, Watson should be moved down the order and Hughes should retain his position to inject some much needed youth into a very old Australian batting line up.

2- No. He’s not an opener.

3- Yes, the selectors have been making poor decisions for a while now.

4- Don’t know, depends I suppose. However, if two are used Steven Smith needs to be the second. Hauritz is nothing more than a stop gap. West Indies and Pakistan are not big names in test cricket at the moment. Good opportunity to blood the person who is most likely to fulfill the spinning duties for Australia into the future.

5- if this attack can’t take 20 wickets against the WINDIES, I will laugh and laugh and point and laugh. There are only 2 quality test batsmen in the WINDIES line up, Chanderpaul and Sarwan.

6- No, but they’re still pretty bad.

7- One of them should ideally still be in the side to help guide around what is a really young and inexperienced bowling attack. Hilditch is a Siddle fan though, and Johnson won’t be kicked out of the team because of how much the current selectors favour all-rounders (Johnson could almost be called a bowling all-rounder right now). So I doubt it.

8- Don’t care. Punter’s a shitty Captain (who only succeeds in leading from the front) and Pup Clarke ain’t much better.

10- Hmmm ,yes, I don’t know about bringing in the crowds, but CA’s innovation has again meant that the Associated Press will not cover the cricket being played in Australia. Good work CA. Top job.

Reply
Kento said | November 26th 2009 @ 10:24am | Report comment

This is the issue with Watson as opener. Any batsman can open and will do well every so often.

Consistency, though, is hard and this is where you need an experienced, trained opener like Rogers or Hughes.

Reply
Fisher Price said | November 26th 2009 @ 10:29am | Report comment

Watson as an opener looks like a walking LBW shout.

Reply
Fred Magee said | November 26th 2009 @ 10:47am | Report comment

He hasnt had a good start…shouldering arms and out for 0. Havent seen it yet to comment but from what i hear, doesnt look good.

Reply
Fisher Price said | November 26th 2009 @ 11:13am | Report comment

I base that assessment as much on the dismissals and favourable umpiring decisions during the Ashes.

Reply
Jameswm said | November 26th 2009 @ 11:19am | Report comment

Our “selectors” haven’t worked out that opening in one-dayers is not the same as opening in tests.

Fact is, they didn’t have the guts to sack Hussey, so leaving Watson at opener was the easy way out.

And forget Hughes – Jaques is the one who should be opening right now, with Kato.

Reply
- Fisher Price said | November 26th 2009 @ 11:25am | Report comment
  
  Hear hear.
  
  Neither Hussey nor Watson should be in the side.
  
  But Punter loves ‘em, so…
  
  Reply
  - davido said | November 26th 2009 @ 11:42am | Report comment
    
    That is pretty harsh on Hussey.
    
    Reply
Fred Magee said | November 26th 2009 @ 11:44am | Report comment

If it werent for his knee injury, Callum Ferguson would have been my pick to replace Hussey. And no one can answer the question as to why Brad Hodge has his file stamped “Never to be selected again”.

I would be happy with Jaques or Hughes.

Reply
- Fisher Price said | November 26th 2009 @ 12:55pm | Report comment
  
  With you on all those points.
  
  Hodge is seemingly not Punter’s glass of Cascade. Rogers neither.
  
  Reply