By Freud of Football -
November 28th 2009 @ 12:53am
Get a Roar profile
Related coverage
Blanc to accede the Manchester United throne?
With Sir Alex Ferguson approaching his 68th birthday, the press speculation as to his eventual successor is about to enter full swing yet again.
Replacing the Scot is a seemingly impossible task, but are the stars aligning for Laurent Blanc to step in?
It is clear that the next in Old Trafford’s hot-seat will need some time to readjust the chair which is now perfectly contoured to Sir Alex’s rear end after 23 years on the throne.
The executives are also aware that they aren’t looking for a mere manager, they need a guru, a win-at-all-costs work ethic simply won’t suffice as Manchester United is as much about a methodology or an ideal as it is about results and profits.
So why does Laurent Blanc fit the bill better than say Carlos Queiroz, Arséne Wenger, Jose Mourinho, David Moyes, Mark Hughes, Steve Bruce, Martin O’Neill or Roy Keane?
Here are the five crucial points.
The Player: The enigmatic Frenchman had a playing career that most others can only dream of with 16 goals and 97 caps for France as well as stints at Barcelona, Marseille, Inter and Manchester United. He was an excellent technician and a defender with prowess who scored a hat full of goals.
We’ve seen with the likes of Paul Ince and Roy Keane, excellent players don’t necessarily make excellent managers, however it does offer a platform that Wenger, Queiroz and Mourinho never had.
The Club: Wenger, Moyes, O’Neill and Mourinho have never played for the club and they have always bought their own ethos to the teams they have managed but United doesn’t need an attitude change, they don’t need a new culture, they need a captain, to come in and steer the ship, someone to take the beliefs of Sir Matt Busby and Sir Alex Ferguson further and pass on a message.
The Titles: He has already proved himself with Bordeaux in winning Ligue 1 and winning titles is something that the likes of Moyes, Hughes, Keane and Bruce – all named as heirs’ apparent – are yet to do at the highest level.
Both Wenger and Mourinho have been successful in England and Europe, Mourinho’s short spell at Chelsea reaped huge rewards while Wenger created the Invincibles, a team that is unlikely to be surpassed in this life time.
Of the other names that are considered to be potential candidates, only O’Neill has had success with Celtic in Scotland and a couple of Carling Cups with Leicester, while Queiroz, it would appear, is a “nearly man”, a great assistant but an ordinary manager.
The Respect: He is obviously admired by Sir Alex as evidenced by his three attempts to sign him as a player (he finally transferred to United in 2001) and two attempts to add him to the coaching staff, both of which he rejected to further his education as a manager, rather than as assistant.
It is widely thought Sir Alex will play a role in determining his successor and as such this relationship of mutual respect could go a long way to Blanc’s appointment.
The X-Factor: He fits the old Dirty Harry saying of; “A man’s got to know his limitations”.
Of the names mentioned, one could only really accuse the overly-ambitious Mourinho and Keane of not knowing their limitations. Importantly, Blanc has had the chance to join Sir Alex at Old Trafford, last summer when Queiroz left to take the reins of the Portuguese national team but he opted to stay on with Bordeaux and continue his development as a head coach, noting, “Two years experience isn’t enough for the top English jobs.
“My ideal career path would be to start in France, then manage abroad, and then return to head the French national team.”
While Mourinho would probably be second favourite, his individualistic ego knows no bounds, Blanc on the other hand is humble enough to know that he is still learning his trade and will always put the club ahead of himself.
Of all the contenders, only Blanc fulfills all five points and that, for mine, puts him ahead of the pack.
You can expect the speculation to begin any day now but could it be that the decision has already been made?
The summer sale of Gabriel Obertan in the summer to United for £3 million has a funny smell about it. While Obertan might have gone to United to further his education, is it thinkable that in conjunction with Sir Alex, Blanc might be looking out for United’s future?
There is also Marounae Chamakh, Arsenal’s main transfer target didn’t end up heading to London when the Gunners needed a replacement for Emmanuel Adebayor, could it be that his retention was in order to send him to Manchester sometime in the future?
Obviously this isn’t based on cold hard facts, but sometimes in football one and one make two, other times you get three.
Blanc might or might not be United’s saviour but “if you want a guarantee, buy a toaster”.
Get Australia's best Football opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...


(6)
![The keen interest shown by Roar readers on my last week’s article, Foreign-born England’s Test Cricketers, has encouraged me to research on overseas-born South African Test cricketers.
South Africa selected their first ever player of Asian origin in their Test team in 2004. Born in Durban, Hashim Amla is a member of the Durban and Kwazulu [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Foreign-born South African Test cricketers](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/foreign-born-south-african-cricket-hashim-amla-graeme-smith-th.jpg)
![The sight of Clint Bolton in a Melbourne Heart polo shirt in the week he wore the gloves for Sydney FC as they began their finals campaign didn’t go down too well with Sydney fans and football purists. But it will go down as a significant moment for Melbourne’s second franchise.
It was the moment they [...] Adrian Musolino: Finally the Melbourne Heart starts pumping](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/melbourne-heart-th.jpg)
![Has FIFA President Sepp Blatter confirmed what we all should have expected? In a press conference in Madrid, Blatter has given his strongest hint yet that the World Cup is destined for a return to Europe in 2018, which would leave Australia with only 2022 as a possibility.
“From what I’ve discussed with the president of [...] Adrian Musolino: Europe set for 2018 World Cup, Australia eyes 2022](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/players-no-benefit-doubt-sepp-blatter-th.jpg)
![Over at Goal.com, my mate John Duerden has a fantastic piece up suggesting Australia and Indonesia combine their World Cup bids to have a shot at either 2018 or 2022.
With the Rio Olympics going to Brazil and the chastened Americans firming as a favourite for 2022 with 2018 inevitably going to Europe, the chances of [...] Jesse Fink: Time for Australia and Indonesia to unite](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/socceroos-2018-egypt-blatter-lowy-th.jpg)
![I know, I know. In the past I have been critical of Ricky Ponting’s leadership and of the Australian selectors’ wisdom. But their performances in the series against India on foreign soil against all odds show that Australia is a champion cricket nation.
Losing nine players through injuries, besides Andrew Symonds and Adam Gilchrist, in [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Hats off to Ponting’s professionals](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/ponting-only-current-player-th.jpg)
![Am I the only person writing on Test cricket these days? After seven One-Day Internationals in England, the ICC Champions Trophy starts the South Africa today, then the Airtel Champions Twenty20 in India starts on October 8, followed by more Fifty50 ODIs between Australia and India in India.
Test matches will recommence in November.
But [...] Kersi Meher-Homji: Short history of foreign-born Australian Test cricketers](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/ipl-mutant-symonds-th.jpg)
![FIFA uses the Confederations Cup as a warm-up for the World Cup, which is good given the problems that have already sprung up. But the off-field issues don’t concern me as much as the on-field ones do.
Egypt is furious after Brazil was awarded a penalty on the basis of a video replay that was screened [...] David Wiseman: FIFA turns a blind eye when it comes to new technology](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/fife-turns-blind-eye-th.jpg)
![Just imagine the following happened: Sydney FC played an A-League home game against the Melbourne Victory at the Sydney Football Stadium as a curtain raiser to the Socceroos-Holland friendly on Saturday night. Yep, I’m dreaming right?
Absolutely.
There are numerous and obvious reasons which would preclude an A-League-Socceroos double billing on the same night.
However, I can’t help [...] Adrian Musolino: FFA needs to look beyond the rules of Marketing 101](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/central-coast-mariners-player-drain-th.jpg)
![Those in positions of power at AFL House are criticised heavily when they do something wrong, so it is only fair we acknowledge them when they do something right. Finally, the league is going to come down on a group of players no one likes – the stagers.
This season will see players fined for faking, [...] Luke D'Anello: AFL to finally rid the game of stagers](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/is-mandatory-helmet-th.jpg)
![He lay prone on the ground. All 189cms of him was still, except for what looked like spasms as his legs lashed out in pain and alone, except for the suspicious looks from the 40,000 people who surrounded him.
“We’ve seen this before” they all thought. “He better get up before he gets substituted off like [...] Davidde Corran: The hypocrisy of referee criticism](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/respect-for-officials-missing-chelsea-drogba-th.jpg)
![When Fox Sports’ tactical formation caption came up ahead of the Gold Coast United’s A-League opener against Brisbane, you could have been forgiven for thinking Miron Bleiberg had pulled one over the Fox producer. It showed the new club shaping up in a rather outrageous looking 2-4-2-2 in front of Scott Higgins.
It featured stoppers [...] Tony Tannous: Advanced wing-backs are key in Bleiberg’s 2-4-2-2](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/gold-coast-expansion-mensink-bleiberg-buckley-th.jpg)
![Last Friday, the Melbourne Knights announced Mark Viduka would be the team’s number one ticket holder for the new Victorian Premier League season.
In an article on the Knights’ website, the former NSL club also revealed that former Socceroo Danny Tiatto would be joining the club for two games as a guest player.
Interesting news that mostly [...] Davidde Corran: Viduka shows the way to embrace football’s roots](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/ACT-government-shoots-viduka-th.jpg)




Roger Rational said | November 28th 2009 @ 11:40am | Report comment
If you think United are going to appoint Laurent Blanc on the back of one French title with Bordeaux, then you are living in cloud cuckoo land. Success in Ligue 1 proves absolutely nothing and should be treated with no more respect than winning the English Championship. Paul Le Guen, Jacques Santini and Alain Perrin won about eight French Championships between them and all proved to be unmitigated disasters in British football.
Blanc might have a chance in eight years, but not before. I’d stick my money on Mourinho. United won’t be looking for potential – they’ll demand the finished product; someone who can guarantee trophies. Mourinho is the nearest thing you’ll find to a toaster in football management.
Freud of Football said | November 28th 2009 @ 7:33pm | Report comment
Arsene Wenger won the title with Monaco and would have won many more if it weren’t for Marseille’s match fixing, he’s produced the best team the EPL has ever seen so you can’t simply discount his achievements because they were in France, yes Ligue 1 isn’t as strong as other leagues, that I’ll certainly concede but Blanc is getting attention (as did Wenger) as much for the way his team is playing as the titles.
Further, if you’ve seen Bordeuax in the CL then you’d know that they aren’t playing schoolboy football, they are playing some beuatiful, free-flowing attacking football, better quality than the German teams and the Spanish sides (outside Real and Barca) even.
Roger Rational said | November 29th 2009 @ 11:18am | Report comment
Fair eough, Freud, but I still don’t think Blanc has a hope in hell’s chance. You simply cannot underestimate just how loathe to experiment the top EPL clubs are nowadays. You joke about guaranteed trophies – but that’s exactly what they demand.
Mattay said | November 29th 2009 @ 11:10am | Report comment
Steve Bruce. Bookmark it.
Roger Rational said | November 29th 2009 @ 11:15am | Report comment
No chance. Bruce is a decent mid-table manager, nothing more. I would give you 10/1 on any British manager getting the job.
Freud of Football said | November 29th 2009 @ 8:49pm | Report comment
I’d take 10/1 on Keane.
As much as he looks like the last man mentioned above to succeed, I think the United execs will likely fall all over themselves when the time comes and stump for Keane as he would be the most “secure” option, he has done some good things as Manager (obviously they wont remind us how crap Sunderland were at the end) and he is by far the most respected of those names amongst the United faithful, for that reason alone the execs would feel comfortable giving him the job, or Eric Cantona, a man with no experience (beach football doesn’t count) but a god to the United crowd, even I’d be over the moon if he got the job although I have no idea how he’d do.
Unfortunately I can’t see it going to Wenger or Mourinho, the two other good candidates for mine. Wenger I’d love to see in the hotseat, if he’d had the academy that United had he could have done anything but there is too much hate towards the man that he’d never take the job if offered it and Mourinho is too much his own man, he needs a blank canvas, that’s why he was successful in Porto and Chelsea, he came in and took them to the top, at Inter he already had a top team and couldn’t stamp his authority on the team the way he wants.