Korean football is better than we thought
By Mike Tuckerman, 19 Mar 2010 Mike Tuckerman is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- A-League, FC Seoul, football, K-League, Simon Colosimo
The news that Sydney FC defender Simon Colosimo looks set to move to the K-League comes as no real surprise. The veteran defender harbours World Cup ambitions, but unless he finds himself a club for the next three months, he won’t be on the plane to South Africa.
Colosimo has been courted by South Korean clubs before, with Chunnam Dragons going close to signing the much-travelled defender at the start of 2009.
Sydney FC’s failure to agree on a transfer fee scotched the deal then, but this time the out-of-contract stopper could be on the first plane over to the Land Of The Morning Calm once the dust settles on Saturday night’s Grand Final.
The move is unlikely to attract an outpouring of derision on A-League message boards that Colosimo is moving to a so-called “lesser league,” partly because the departure of a peripatetic 31-year-old is not necessarily seen as a crippling blow.
But surely some recent results have also played their part, with a largely domestic-based Korea Republic humbling the Socceroos in Seoul six months ago, while unfancied K-League outfit Pohang Steelers lifted the Asian Champions League trophy last December.
All credit to Adelaide United for beating defending champions Pohang in their Champions League opener last month, but perhaps there’s a growing realisation that Korean football is not quite the step down in class that many Australian fans originally thought.
Jade North certainly discovered a competitive environment when he lobbed up at Incheon United, although it was probably the fact that Serbian coach Ilija Petkovic simply didn’t rate him that persuaded North to up sticks to Norwegian side Tromsø.
Watching the highlights of FC Seoul’s top-of-the-table clash with Jeonbuk Hyundai Motors this week, I was struck by just how much there is to admire about the Korean game.
The late miss from FC Seoul striker Jung Jo-Gook was comical – not only because it was a simple chance – but also because the pyrotechnicans on hand inadvertently set off the post-goal fireworks.
But aside from Jung’s blemish, all the hallmarks of Korean football were on display – the rapid movement, the crisp passing and the more physical style that sets the K-League apart from its better-known Japanese counterpart.
There are still plenty of problems in Korean football, of course, not limited to a penchant for signing mediocre foreigners over local talent.
Military side Gwangju Sangmu regularly finish bottom – not surprisingly, since their players only spend two years with the club and Gwangju can’t sign any foreigners – while attendance figures across the league appear to be routinely exaggerated.
Nevertheless, what the K-League does offer are some decent wages and a more robust style of football than is found in neighbouring Japan.
These days it’s also an unpredictable league, with no less than five different winners claiming the title in the past five seasons.
Current holders Jeonbuk Hyundai Motors can claim former Middlesbrough striker Lee Dong-Gook and giant front man Sim Woo-Yeon among their ranks, and the team from Jeolla Province once again look the side to beat in 2010.
They’ll face some stiff competition from perennial challengers Seongnam Ilhwa, the ambitious Pohang and capital club FC Seoul, while Colosimo’s two potential suitors Chunnam and Incheon will also hope to have their say in the title race.
Regardless of whom Colosimo signs for – and that’s provided that he does join a club in South Korea – he can expect a warm welcome when he touches down in the ancient land.
There’s a healthy respect for Australian footballers in South Korea, and recent results suggest that the feeling may soon be mutual.
It’s a shame that we don’t see much Korean football on Australia TV, but should Simon Colosimo make the K-League his next port of call, he’ll certainly hope that Pim Verbeek is keeping close tabs on him.
Follow Mike on twitter @Mike_Tuckerman
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- A-League, FC Seoul, football, K-League, Simon Colosimo


AndyRoo said | March 19th 2010 @ 8:48am | Report comment
The K league also has 3 young players transfer to very good overseas clubs (Celtic, Bolton and Ajax) in the last 12 months so their probably set for a bit of a golden period over the next 5 to 10 years.
I think Buyn and Song have been good additions to the A league (haven’t see enough of Shin) so hopefully the player exchanges go both ways because like Australian’s the Koreans are often the plus 1 AFC player at a lot of clubs.
TheMagnificent11 said | March 19th 2010 @ 10:11am | Report comment
I think Korea is the best footballing nation in the AFC. The Japanese are probably the most technical and we probably have the best physical and mental strength. However, as a whole package, the Koreans take the cake IMO. They are more clinical than Japanese and their passing and movement is far better than ours. The K-League is not as good as the J-League, but it’s probably the second best league in Asia. Colosimo is definitely making a step up in standard.
Ben of Phnom Penh said | March 19th 2010 @ 11:02am | Report comment
It is true that we do tend to focus upon the J-League and tend to forget the game just across the straits of Tsushima (or will be across from the straits of Tsushima when V-Varen Nagasaki finally make it to the J-League….. which they’ll naturally dominate or when Avispa Fukuoka finally work out they are actually a big club and shouldn’t be in J2). Partly this is due to the strength of the J-League, however I think much of it comes from the fact that many more Australians have spent time living and working in Japan than Korea and as a result have more of an affinity with the Land of the Rising Sun.
From the little Korean football I’ve seen it appears that the K-League could confidently take the title of second best league in East Asia (I’ve yet to see the domestic game in Iran). Australian clubs still have someway to go and I’d be very surprised if anyone saw Colosimo’s move as a step backwards. Besides he’s now 31, towards the end of his career, and he still has the chance to travel the world and be paid well for it. Power to him.
dasilva said | March 19th 2010 @ 12:34pm | Report comment
Actually I think australia focus on J-league more because our clubs generally lose to them. An Australian club has only beaten a J-league club once (Adelaide vs Kashima). We have also lost to them in a decent margin as well not just the ACL but the Pan-pacific cup as well.
Korea on the other hand, A-League clubs have a pretty decent record against them and I believe we have beaten them fair amount more then they have beaten us (although admittingly Pohang gave Newcastle jets a big flogging last time they played). Adelaide record against Pohang steelers have been 3 zip and they are probably the best Korean side.
Funny thing is that I read that the J-league club’s record against K-league team has generally been poor with the Koreans having the overall lead in the win-loss record.
TheMagnificent11 said | March 19th 2010 @ 12:43pm | Report comment
You’re comparing the top clubs for each league against each other. That is not a true reflection of the entire league. That’s like saying the EPL is the best league in Europe because they got most of the semi-final places in the UCL. All that proves is that the EPL’s best clubs are better than the best clubs in other leagues. The overall strength of the K-League is going to be better than the A-League because they have more money and invest more money in youth development, foreign coaches and foreign players. Also, traditionally, east Asian countries focus more on technical development when compared to Anglo countries. Technically they are far superior to us.
Also, those wins Adelaide had over Pohang were based around strong defensive performances. They didn’t control possession and win convincingly.
AndyRoo said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:06pm | Report comment
In the A leagues defence the gap between the best team and the worst team is very small because of the salary cap. Twice we have teams who qualified for the ACL and then by the time they actually played in the ACL had finished in last place the next year (Jets last year and Adelaide this year).
All the teams are pretty decent in the J league (thanks to the existence of J2 to get rid of the wretched ones) but Korea doesn’t have promotion and relegation and has a few strugglers. Their top teams are allowed to be the best that they can be so their domestic structure and season timing should be more of an advantage for the ACL.
But it’s true the K league teams while not getting the results against us generally look better than the A league teams. I don’t think Dasilva was saying the A league is better, just that the J league is the best and that’s what we focus on.
Davstar said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:21pm | Report comment
TheMagnificent – i’d like to say italy has won 4 would cups and they play defensive football what is our point about Adelaide United? nothing wrong with it not conceeding its actually the best way to play cup football. As for the EPL being the best Fulham just beat Juva 4-1
dasilva said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:37pm | Report comment
All i’m saying is that if the Korean clubs were consistently beating A-league clubs (like the Japanese are) then the Australian football public would have certainly take the K-League a lot more seriously.
Now whether the K-league is a higher standard then A-league. Probably due to the money and the ability to attract better foreign players (similar to what Ogre said) and a higher technical standard but I don’t think the difference is a huge amount.
StiflersMom said | March 19th 2010 @ 12:55pm | Report comment
Seriously Mike, If Pim picks Colosimo for the World Cup and over looks Sasha then all respect for Pim is out the window, and he won’t be able to call the “age” factor either, sasha is younger then Neil, Moore and Colosimo.
Watching Sasha against Melbourne it was clear he was well motivated and at the top of his game, and he’s captian to boot.
The Korean league seems to have improved Sasha’s game out of sight and I believe at this point he may be one of the best defenders Australia or Macedoinia have to offer.
TheMagnificent11 said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:27pm | Report comment
I don’t think Ognenovski can play for Australia. Hasn’t he already represented Macedonia?
StiflersMom said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:56pm | Report comment
He was called up into the squad but was not in the playing team
Mike Tuckerman said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:01pm | Report comment
It seems to be a personality clash with Ognenovski, more than anything else. He’s certainly been playing well for Seongnam of late.
punter said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:23pm | Report comment
That seems quite obvious & that’s the big shame. Ogenovski is the best option for Pim to partner Neill at the WC.
Craig Moore is a legend & his experience is invaluable but even a blind man can tell you, he is not the player he was in 06.
Spiranovic unfortunately hasn’t got game time to develop into the player we require by 3 months time.
Ogenovski is better than any other CB we have available.
AndyRoo said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:28pm | Report comment
Wasn’t their an incident involving Ogenovski in the first round of ACL matches this year where he was involved in a very bad tackle.
That may have something to do with it. Like Griffifths he may be one of those players who are talented but not deemed cool headed enough for international football.
Just a theory though, I haven’t seen him play very often.
Mike Tuckerman said | March 19th 2010 @ 1:38pm | Report comment
He came in half-a-step late to an aerial challenge with Kawasaki Frontale playmaker Kengo Nakamura and ended up shattering his jaw.
Punter said | March 19th 2010 @ 2:52pm | Report comment
Yes another unusal one, I cannot believe that both Ogenovski & Griffiths cannot get into any Asian based socceroos squad.
Must be more into it, althought PIM did say he would look into Griffiths if he continues to play well.
Davstar said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:29pm | Report comment
Colosimo wont get called up th SA and the K-league isnt better much better then the A-league no offence.
IMO no league in the AFC is any good however the J-league is clearly the best but i’ve notice one thing about most teams our A-league clubs play in the AFC there best players are all internationals (esp. strikers) kind-off like the EPL with a sprinkle of decent domestic players.
Spiranovic/Lowry/Rhy will get called up ahead of him simply because they’re younger, they all have been called up to the Euro-ross squad. If he takes 6-8 defenders: Neil, Moor, Kissa, Chipper(if he’s not injuried), Whilk and Carney(if he’s not injuried)have got that covered.
Punter said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:38pm | Report comment
I disagree, technically, both the Korean & Chinese teams have looked much better than Melbourne Victory. However, in the A-League Melbourne looks the best team technically .
David V. said | March 19th 2010 @ 3:47pm | Report comment
How can you say no league in Asia is any good?
The J-League has much greater depth of homegrown talent, to the extent that even J2 clubs boast some excellent technical ball players. That’s better than some European leagues can boast these days.
Davstar said | March 19th 2010 @ 7:50pm | Report comment
I dont rate asian leagues its as simple as that the fact the AUFC beat the champions of Asia is all the arguement i need. The Steelers have about 12 times the funds AUFC have Adelaide uniteds squad is made largely of domestic kids playing in local league aka. guys i used to play soccer with.
Flores comes from 2nd div argentina and dibbled past half the steelers mid-feild, Leckie 12 month ago was in the vic premier league he dibbled 3 defenders and scored.
AUFC have beat Steelers 3 times defensively they played but there is nothing wrong with that. Inter played defensive against Chelsea and look there in the last 8 of the CL, Greece won the euro 2004 playing defensive its how a smart coach plays in cup competitions people want to see there teams win hence why no one goes to the Victory ACL matches.
Hell Australia play defensive and they are doing alright
Ben of Phnom Penh said | March 19th 2010 @ 8:38pm | Report comment
and not to forget the total dominance of the competition from Melbourne, Sydney, Newcastle and Central Coast……
David V. said | March 19th 2010 @ 8:38pm | Report comment
I agree they aren’t all *that* good, but what about the fact Gamba defeated both Melbourne and Adelaide, scoring a fair few goals in the process? Or Kawasaki Frontale hammering the Mariners? The J-League can legitimately compete with European and South American leagues for the quality of players they produce.
David V. said | March 19th 2010 @ 8:54pm | Report comment
Oh and I want to see teams play more attractive and attacking football. After all, Brian Clough disparaged those who played long ball and catenaccio crap and rightly so!
clayton said | March 19th 2010 @ 4:33pm | Report comment
Watched the Korea vs Japan game in the East Asian Championships (two home based squads). The men in red were pretty impressive. Their wide men were very confident and ran at their defenders. Strong, hard-running team.
AndyRoo said | March 19th 2010 @ 4:43pm | Report comment
I watched that one too, was a pretty physical encounter.
Poor Strebre had to use about 5 a league matches worth of cards
David V. said | March 19th 2010 @ 5:12pm | Report comment
Why disparage leagues outside Europe- namely the Americas, or EA/ME/NA (East Asia/Middle East/North Africa)? They are such rich nurseries in their own right and competitions worth watching, of which I’ve watched my fair share.