Final seven and wildcard play-off makes perfect sense
By Justin Rodski, 16 Jul 2010 Justin Rodski is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- AFL, AFL finals, Greater Western Sydney
As the league considers its options for a new finals structure, they should look no further than the events of this season when making a decision. A final 7 and a wildcard playoff between eighth and ninth spot will not only help invigorate the build-up to September, but also give the regular season another dimension.
With the introduction of the Gold Coast and Greater Western Sydney teams over the next two years, many alternatives have been floated, including a locked fixture over three years, a final twelve, a conference system and even a reset fixture at round 17.
But what we’ve seen in 2010 is a perfect example of just how beneficial a wildcard playoff for a spot in the finals would be, especially compared to the often anti-climatic end to the home and away season.
Instead of all these dead rubbers, with teams playing for nothing else but pride, a possible wildcard entry into September for the team that finishes ninth will create an added level of excitement that we’ve never had before.
In a sense it’s a mini grand final at the end of round 22, eighth versus ninth in a do or die clash for that last spot in the finals.
Last year we had this situation by virtue of the draw, and it was only a coincidence that Hawthorn and Essendon played off at the MCG for eighth spot.
The match was befitting a final.
It was high scoring and frenetic, and had just about everything, including a massive crowd, an all in brawl, and that now infamous shirt front from Matthew Lloyd on Brad Sewell.
Let this be a lesson for the AFL of just how good this wildcard concept has the potential to be.
The actual format of the final eight as we know it would remain the same, but it becomes a final 7 and at the end of the home and away season, the teams that finished eight and ninth effectively play for eighth spot.
If we consider that with 7 rounds still to go this season, and with the final 8 basically already locked in, crowd attendances, interest in games and general apathy towards matches involving the bottom 8 teams will really start to set in.
So why not give them something to play for? What if we had a wildcard entry in the finals?
Right now, as it stands, we have seven teams that would still be in the hunt for ninth spot on the ladder, North Melbourne on 28 points, Adelaide on 24, Melbourne on 22 and Brisbane, Essendon, Port Adelaide and Richmond all on 20 points.
Just imagine how excited Tiger fans would be? Six weeks ago, many thought they wouldn’t even win a game this season, let alone be a chance to play finals.
How ironic too for the Tigers faithful. Finally the club would rewarded for finishing ninth, not ridiculed.
It also allows forgiveness for some of the many variables that can affect a football club, whether it’s a team decimated by injury in the early rounds, or a run of close losses. Either way, this keeps the season alive for almost the whole competition right to the very end.
The ‘form ladder’ from the last couple of months shows Richmond and Adelaide are playing as well as anyone. So maybe they could end up being the sleeping giants that take advantage of the wildcard and do something special in September?
The other huge benefit is it will help to eliminate teams ‘tanking’ games in the latter part of the season. While it’s not an issue in the next few years due to the massive draft concessions going to the two new franchises, in 2013 the priority pick and tanking issue will be once again back on the agenda.
However, with this system, teams will be more interested in fighting for a chance to play-off in the wildcard game than throwing matches for future draft picks.
Exactly when the play-off would be though is problematic and requires more thought and consideration, could it be a stand alone game in between the last round of the season and the finals series?
Either way, it’s an attractive option with plenty of positives.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (12) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- AFL, AFL finals, Greater Western Sydney

Mega said | July 16th 2010 @ 2:09am | Report comment
Like the idea but a playoff just complicates things too much. Keep it simple.
PS: If there was a final seven with a playoff between eight, nine and ten, Richmond would start finishing 11th.
counterruck said | July 16th 2010 @ 2:34am | Report comment
once the 18 teams are up and running why not reduce the regular season to 18 weeks. one full round (17 games), and an additional fixutre against a crosstown rival. then you could expand the finals to 12 teams, knockout.
Adam said | July 16th 2010 @ 7:10am | Report comment
I think the most important thing the AFL needs to do is keep the current format for the grandfinal. Last weekend of September has become an institution, much like the timing of the Melbourne cup.
Fivehole said | July 16th 2010 @ 8:48am | Report comment
Stupid idea – they’ll be so drained from this game that they’ll get smashed in the first week of the proper finals
Harvey the Scouser said | July 16th 2010 @ 9:09am | Report comment
although the idea of a free weekend (after rd 22) for the widlcard playoff has merit, given the current floating round 22 concept, i.e. the top 7 would have a bye, and there’d be no angst about who had the most time off, etc.
Gerta said | July 16th 2010 @ 9:27am | Report comment
Super idea Justin, interesting concept.
Hammer1 said | July 16th 2010 @ 10:39am | Report comment
Whay not extend on this idea, have 2 wildcard games i.e. 7v10 and 8v9. 1-6 get a week off and let’s face it 99.99% of the time the winner is going to come from the top 6 (top 4 really). Gives those teams a chance but also creates some interest in 7-10th spot. though it makes it pretty hard to win from 10, but fans from those teams can still dare to dream!
tomdp58 said | July 16th 2010 @ 10:47am | Report comment
gold! the last few rounds definitely need some excitment. the home and away season is long enough, I’d like to see a longer and better finals series..
Mega said | July 16th 2010 @ 12:58pm | Report comment
I guess the best example of playoff success is in the English second division for promotion to the EPL. Whatever system the AFL try, if it’s a real departure from what we have now, it’ll take a while for fans to get used to it so there will be some initial dislikes..
Harvey the Scouser said | July 16th 2010 @ 5:12pm | Report comment
play offs in the football world are a very recent phenomenon
Black Diamonds said | October 15th 2010 @ 9:49am | Report comment
Not really, Australian Football has been using playoffs since at least 1897 – that’s a fair tradition.
ahahahaha said | November 30th 2010 @ 12:29pm | Report comment
if it aint broke..