It’s kick-off time for another edition of the AFC Champions League, and that can only mean one thing – the ready-made excuses will start coming thick and fast from Australian fans, media and occasionally, even A-League clubs themselves.
“Cashed up”, “heavyweights”, “endless resources”; they’re all claims we’ve heard before and for the most part they have no basis.
It would be wrong to completely ignore the fact that J.League, K-League and CSL clubs do have more money at their disposal, but to use it as justification or an excuse for why their clubs have success over A-League sides masks the real disparity between the nations.
That comes at a more basic youth development level.
Take Gamba Osaka for example. Three of their starting XI in the first leg of the 2008 ACL Final, as well as Takumi Shimohira who came off the bench, are products of the Gamba Osaka youth system.
Two of those players, Takahiro Futagawa and Hideo Hashimoto, as well as Shimohira, are still with the club, while Michihiro Yasuda left during the January transfer window for Vitesse Arnhem in Holland.
The latest off-the-production-line, Takashi Usami, is rated as the best player to come through the Gamba Osaka youth system and already has Bayern Munich interested in him. All this for a kid who is only 18 years old.
Sydney’s J.League opponents this year, Kashima Antlers, are in a similar boat. Two of their starting XI from the weekend’s Super Cup have come through the Kashima youth system, while another handful was plucked straight from High School and have spent their entire careers with Ibaraki-based club.
It is these youth systems that currently set Japan, in particular, apart from Australia.
Any new side that wishes to enter the J.League, be it in J1 or J2, must have an U18, U15 and U12 team to complement their senior team.
Not only does this ensure a strong connection with their local community, something that has been critical in seeing crowds rise over the last decade, it also allows the clubs to work with their best local talent from an early age.
Doing so, gets them into the “system” and by the time they are in their late teens, many are ready to take the step up to senior team action.
Compare that to the A-League where it is left to local clubs with part-time coaches to nurture our best talent until they reach an age where they are eligible for the National Youth League.
Even then there is often a large disconnect between the NYL side and A-League side.
This year’s ACL has yet to kick off and already the same excuses are being bandied about.
Grantley Bernard, writing in the Herald Sun on Saturday, got the ball rolling when he wrote, “… (that’s) all part of the test against big Asian teams that have unlimited resources and money while the A-League teams in the Champions League remain restricted by the salary cap and squad sizes.”
It is lazy and innacurate to focus purely on the monetary aspect and it serves Australia no good as it looks to gain more respect within the AFC.
It’s the old Aussie arrogance rearing its ugly head again – it’s not that they’re better than us, it’s just they have more money!
Instead of focusing on that one aspect, fans, media and clubs would be better served by actually learning a few lessons from a league that has been there and done that when it comes to setting up a new league and new teams.
They may just be surprised by what they find.
Are you the ultimate team manager? Pick your own superstar team and go head to head with other football fans for glory and cash prizes on Draftstars. Imagine what you could be buying instead. Set a deposit limit.
Here is the way the Roar expert panel sees all the action unfolding across the final weekend of play prior to the semi-finals.
It was not too long ago that it was no guarantee that the best youth talents from South Australia would make their A-League debuts…
Even though St.Pauli ultimately lost a high-scoring affair, Jackson Irvine was a standout, as well as scoring a late goal.
Mathew Leckie played a pivotal part in Melbourne City claiming an 8-nil win; playing a role in several of his team's goals.
A 10-man Macarthur FC have scored twice in the final 10 minutes and goalkeeper Filip Kurto saved an added-time penalty to defeat Adelaide United…
Clubs have cited regulations claiming players who decline national team call-ups ought to be prevented from featuring at a domestic level.
