AFL Round 8 preview panel

By John Salvado,

 , ,

9 Have your say

    Preview of AFL Round 8 matches (all times AEST).

    FRIDAY, May 18
    Collingwood v Geelong at MCG 7.50pm
    Head to Head: Magpies 126 Cats 95 drawn 1
    Last clash: Grand Final 2011 – Cats 18.11 (119) bt Magpies 12.9 (81) at MCG
    Tab Sportsbet: Magpies $1.70 Cats $2.15
    Sportingbet: Magpies $1.70 Cats $2.15

    You would have had long odds at the start of the season that the first clash between the Magpies and the Cats since the epic 2011 grand final would be between teams ranked seventh and 10th on the ladder. In so far as it is possible for the biggest club in the competition, Collingwood have been flying under the radar for the past few weeks. Not so the Cats, who’ve endured a rare spell of uncomfortable scrutiny in the wake of a drubbing by Adelaide.

    Key: The return of triple-premiership stars Jimmy Bartel, Mathew Stokes and Matthew Scarlett is sure to lift the proud Cats, who were humiliated last weekend by the Crows. But will it be enough? The Magpies regain Darren Jolly, Dale Thomas, Chris Dawes and Alex Fasolo.

    Tip: Cats by 10 points

    SATURDAY, May 19
    Port Adelaide v North Melbourne at AAMI Stadium 1.45pm
    Head to Head: Power 7 North Melbourne 19
    Last clash: Round 14 2011 – North Melbourne 21.10 (136) bt Power 14.7 (91) at AAMI Stadium
    Tab Sportsbet: Power $2.75 North Melbourne $1.45
    Sportingbet: Power $2.75 North Melbourne $1.45

    North Melbourne coach Brad Scott promised heads would roll after the embarrassing loss to the Western Bulldogs and it was Liam Anthony who copped the selectors’ axe in the neck, replaced by Levi Greenwood. Port coach Matthew Primus must also be fast losing patience with some big-name members of his team who are riding a six-match losing streak. David Rodan was one of four players dropped. At least the return of key forward Jay Schulz from an eye injury should straighten up the Power in attack.

    Key: With big Kangaroo Hamish McIntosh sidelined with a knee complaint, Todd Goldstein gets the chance to reprise the solo rucking role he performed to great effect in 2011.

    Tip: North Melbourne by 22 points

    Hawthorn v Fremantle at Aurora Stadium 2.10pm
    Head to Head: Hawks 18 Dockers 7
    Last clash: Round 19 2011 – Hawks 13.17 (95) bt Dockers 6.8 (44) at Subiaco
    Tab Sportsbet: Hawks $1.19 Dockers $4.75
    Sportingbet: Hawks $1.18 Dockers $4.80

    If Ross Lyon can mastermind a win over Hawthorn in Launceston – a place where the Dockers have traditionally struggled – it will be the clearest sign yet of the positive effect he’s having at his new club. With the 500-goal milestone out of the way, Dockers’ skipper Matthew Pavlich could be set for a big day. The Hawks will be strengthened by the return of defender Josh Gibson from injury although Michael Osborne (knee) is a loss.

    Key: The Hawks’ undersized ruck division will have their hands full containing Aaron Sandilands. After all, who doesn’t? But if they go close to breaking even, it will be a big win for Hawthorn.

    Tip: Hawks by 29 points

    Sydney v Melbourne at SCG 4.40pm
    Head to Head: Swans 106 Demons 92 drawn 2
    Last clash: Round 1 2011 – Demons 11.18 (84) drew Swans 11.18 (84) at MCG
    Tab Sportsbet: Swans $1.08 Demons $8.00
    Sportingbet: Swans $1.09 Demons $7.50

    Sydney co-captain Jarrad McVeigh readily admits the Swans’ players embarrassed themselves in last weekend’s capitulation to Richmond. It’s unlikely to happen two weeks in a row. The Demons haven’t played at the SCG in five years – a quirky venue where Sydney make the most of a distinct home-ground advantage. Full-forward Mitch Clark and fullback James Frawley have been two of the few Demons who can hold their heads high in what has been a miserable year for the club, while Jack Watts, Liam Jurrah and Brad Green have been recalled. Irishman Tommy Walsh will finally make his AFL debut for the Swans.

    Key: Sydney hard nuts such as Jude Bolton and Josh Kennedy will have taken McVeigh’s barbs personally, which is bad news for the Dees.

    Tip: Swans by 52 points

    Western Bulldogs v Gold Coast at TIO Stadium 7.40pm
    Head to Head: Bulldogs 2 Suns 0
    Last clash: Round 14 2011 – Bulldogs 17.8 (110) bt Suns 13.10 (88) at Gold Coast Stadium
    Tab Sportsbet: Bulldogs $1.15 Suns $5.50
    Sportingbet: Bulldogs $1.17 Suns $5.00

    As a fledgling club, Gold Coast and their coach Guy McKenna have understandably been cut plenty of slack. But the honeymoon period effectively ended following last weekend’s loss to first-year outfit GWS. In their first trip to Darwin, the Suns will need to show plenty against the Bulldogs. Oddly, they have played better this year when superstar Gary Ablett has been sidelined, forcing his teammates to pick up the slack.

    Key: Bulldogs’ great Doug Hawkins has tagged Ryan Griffen as the team’s modern-day Rolls Royce and a Brownlow medallist in the making. High praise indeed.

    Tip: Bulldogs by 30 points

    Essendon v Richmond at MCG 7.50pm
    Head to Head: Bombers 101 Tigers 84 drawn 4
    Last clash: Round 16 2011 – Bombers 15.15 (105) bt Tigers 9.12 (66) at MCG
    Tab Sportsbet: Bombers $1.50 Tigers $2.60
    Sportingbet: Bombers $1.52 Tigers $2.50

    This shapes as the biggest “clash of the sash” since the two traditional Melbourne clubs met in the 2001 final series. The 6-1 Bombers are flying having ended West Coast’s unbeaten run in commanding style last week. And there is plenty to like about the Tigers as well – especially their blue-chip midfield of Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Brett Deledio and Nathan Foley. A crowd of 90,000 is expected for the annual Dreamtime at the ‘G clash.

    Key: Ivan “The Mullet” Maric has been heroic in the ruck for Richmond this year but he faces a massive task against in-form Bombers duo Tom Bellchambers and Paddy Ryder.

    Tip: Bombers by 10 points

    SUNDAY, May 20
    Brisbane v Greater Western Sydney at Gabba 1.10pm
    Head to Head: Lions 0 Giants 0
    Last clash: N/A
    Tab Sportsbet: Lions $1.18 Giants $4.90
    Sportingbet: Lions $1.20 Giants $4.50

    Brisbane skipper Jonathan Brown has laid down the law to the Lions’ players, telling them they are responsible for another poor start to the season – not coach Michael Voss. And when Brown talks, people listen, which isn’t good news for the young Giants. But Kevin Sheedy’s team will arrive at the Gabba in a buoyant mood having claimed their first win last weekend against the Suns. Stephen Coniglio was a deserving Rising Star nominee – the Giants’ third in the space of seven weeks.

    Key: The Lions simply can’t afford to become the first club to lower their colours to the two expansion outfits.

    Tip: Lions by 38 points

    Carlton v Adelaide at Etihad Stadium 3.15pm
    Head to Head: Blues 16 Crows 14
    Last clash: Round 5 2011 – Blues 11.19 (85) bt Crows 12.7 (79) at Etihad Stadium
    Tab Sportsbet: Blues $1.35 Crows $3.25
    Sportingbet: Blues $1.40 Crows $2.95

    Adelaide have been super-impressive this year under new coach Brenton Sanderson – with the exception of their only previous trip to Melbourne which ended in a humbling loss to Hawthorn. They won’t want to produce a repeat effort at Etihad Stadium against Carlton, who were outclassed at the same venue by St Kilda last week. Marc Murphy was a non-factor against the Saints and he rarely plays two bad ones in a row.

    Key: Coleman Medal pacesetter Taylor Walker has been a revelation for Adelaide this year and will be sorely missed due to suspension while pacy defender Chris Yarran’s return is a boost for the Blues.

    Tip: Blues by 20 points

    West Coast v St Kilda at Subiaco 4.40pm
    Head to Head: Eagles 20 Saints 17 drawn 1
    Last clash: Round 17 2011 – Saints 13.4 (82) bt Eagles 9.7 (61) at Etihad Stadium
    Tab Sportsbet: Eagles $1.40 Saints $3.00
    Sportingbet: Eagles $1.40 Saints $2.95

    The Eagles will be mightily relieved that the case of food poisoning that caused Daniel Kerr’s head to swell up is unlikely to result in him missing any football. But they will be sweating on the availability of fellow midfield tyro Matt Priddis, who was heavily concussed last weekend. St Kilda had a huge nine-goal return from their three small forwards Stephen Milne, Terry Milera and Ahmed Saad in the round-seven win over Carlton and would love something similar this time around.

    Key: West Coast’s Dean Cox would fancy his chances of shading the ruck contests on his own. However Cox has been named in the forward pocket and Nic Naitanui returns from injury to first ruck, leaving the Eagles odds-on to dominate in this crucial area of the contest.

    Tip: Eagles by 18 points

    © AAP 2018

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (9)

    • May 18th 2012 @ 8:36am
      GrantS said | May 18th 2012 @ 8:36am | ! Report

      It seems like a pretty straight forward round with Collingwood versus Geelong the only close game where the bookies think there could be a draw and have lowered the price from $67 to $51.

      Collingwood by 9 (take the draw as well), Roos by 20, Hawthorn by 40, Sydney by 60, Bulldogs by 60, Essendon by 30, Brisbane by 35, Carlton by 23, West Coast by 32.

    • Roar Guru

      May 18th 2012 @ 8:49am
      Redb said | May 18th 2012 @ 8:49am | ! Report

      Cracking round of footy.

      In order of importance:

      Geel v Coll
      Essv Rich
      Carl v Adel
      Haw v Freo
      WCE v St Kilda
      Bris v GWS
      Port v North
      Syd v Melb
      WB v GC

      Probably the round of the year to date.



      • Roar Guru

        May 20th 2012 @ 7:08pm
        Redb said | May 20th 2012 @ 7:08pm | ! Report

        That’s 9. 🙂

    • Roar Guru

      May 18th 2012 @ 4:56pm
      The Cattery said | May 18th 2012 @ 4:56pm | ! Report

      Even with a game in Darwin, there’s a chance of breaking the all time attendance record for round 8, currently stands at 309k, last season and in 2005.

      • Roar Guru

        May 20th 2012 @ 7:37pm
        The Cattery said | May 20th 2012 @ 7:37pm | ! Report

        By my reckoning, attendances for Rd 8 come to 302k, so that’s a bit short of the Rd 8 record.

        Rd 8 this year obviously includes an extra game, but also included 8k in Darwin for Dogs vs suns, and 13k in Lonnie for Hawthorn vs Freo.

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2012 @ 10:29am
      The Cattery said | May 19th 2012 @ 10:29am | ! Report

      Niall McKeever has been named as an emergency for Brisbane, but if he gets a last minute call up to the match day team, that will make it five Irishmen playing in the one round of footy, which would represent a record for the AFL.

      The other four are Tommy Walsh (on debut for the Swans this round); Zach Tuohy; Pearce Hanley; and Marty Clarke (who played last night in the pies’ close one against the cats).

    • Roar Guru

      May 19th 2012 @ 11:21am
      The Cattery said | May 19th 2012 @ 11:21am | ! Report

      The top 3 sharp shooters to round 7:

      Justin Koschitzke: 15.0
      Chris Mayne (Freo): 13.0
      Jeremy Cameron (GWS): 10.0

      • May 19th 2012 @ 11:36am
        Cameron said | May 19th 2012 @ 11:36am | ! Report

        Thats very interesting that such a maligned player like Koschitzke has kicked 15 straight

        • Roar Guru

          May 19th 2012 @ 11:49am
          The Cattery said | May 19th 2012 @ 11:49am | ! Report

          Very true – nothing short of a miracle.

          I’m curious now as to what the AFL record is – he must be pretty close to it.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,