The Roar
The Roar

Clyde Rathbone

Expert

Joined February 2012

209k

Views

50

Published

40

Comments

26 caps for the Wallabies and stints with the Sharks and Brumbies in Super Rugby. Clyde is a Co-founder of Karma (https://karma.wiki/app/start/landing), a platform for writing and receiving open letters.

Published

Comments

Except that in many cases “opportunity” creates the illusion of capacity.

RATHBONE: Athletes are just people, so why expect them to be role models?

I’m not sure why you think my article is in any way in opposition to “Ben Daley’s attitude to being a great role model”.

RATHBONE: Athletes are just people, so why expect them to be role models?

Harry, I agree. I’m not arguing that all people shouldn’t aspire to be role models (defined as acting in a way that produces more moral outcomes). I’m arguing against the assumption that athletes are role models, not the fact that they should aspire to be.

RATHBONE: Athletes are just people, so why expect them to be role models?

All life is a canvas and we are all artists, but few seem to know that we paint what we choose 🙂

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

You’ve missed the point by a rather wide margin. The piece briefly interrogates the value of sport. It is not a comment on the relative privilege of athletes (we are wildly privileged).

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

It’s the “handy” part I’m not convinced of. The simple question is this: Is the time many fans devote to professional sport the best use of their time? It’s a subjective question that I think more people should consider

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

If not the real world in what world does professional sport exist? You’re making an argument against a position I’ve not taken.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

I don’t see any problem with loosing oneself in a moment and passionately supporting a team…so long as one can move into the next moment without being affected by the first 🙂

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

Vital, important, relevant…Semantics. When governments contribute millions of tax payer dollars to professional sport it’s clear that it’s taken extremely seriously.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

It makes no more sense to demand an athlete be a role model that it does to make the same demand of anybody else. Also, I’ve never really found a definition of “role model” that could be pressed into every persons idea of what one should look like.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

grapeseed, I think the core difference between “elite employment” and professional sport is the level of personal growth required to excel at each. How much development must the best surgeon in the world undergo vs the best athlete? I think this is an important question.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

Thanks Robert…

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

I think players in the past (amateur days) were forced to become more rounded individuals. Having a ‘real’ job, studying and having significant time away sport leads to a healthy perspective – the type of which is so often lacking today.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

We have a kitchen, Brain, our cook is outstanding and suitably cantankerous as to fit the profile. The boys eat very well indeed.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

All things in moderation…including moderation.

RATHBONE: Does sport really warrant our reverence?

close