The Roar
The Roar

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie

Joined May 2019

71k

Views

29

Published

12.5k

Comments

Published

Comments

Come off it Brendan, no way does Munster win that comp if Leinster play their strongest available team in the semi. The rest were all playing for second best.

The difference is that the Saders aren’t prioritising another comp, they and everyone else are equally trying their utmost to win Super Rugby. Every year the winner deserves it. It’s not the same in Europe.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

You’d only have to hold the Heineken final two or three weeks earlier than it was last year.

Mediocre Munster were rewarded with a URC title they never would have won had Leinster not played a B team in the semi, which in turn rewarded them with a Heineken seeding.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

For me it’s simple – finish the Heineken earlier so the best teams get a fair chance in both. Otherwise you’re rewarding mediocrity.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

Very few of the top 50 got there with those sort of picks 😂

'Last few years have been hell': Iceman 2.0 Harrison gets 'dream come true' in Tahs' stunning golden point win

Don’t worry they’ll find something to moan about

'Last few years have been hell': Iceman 2.0 Harrison gets 'dream come true' in Tahs' stunning golden point win

Are you not ENTERTAINED????!!!!

'Last few years have been hell': Iceman 2.0 Harrison gets 'dream come true' in Tahs' stunning golden point win

And the bus isn’t going to Marry McLaughlin-Phillips 😂

'Brain explosion': Wallaby stars sent off as Queensland left red-faced in Moana Pasifika shocker

That just highlights how fake the Heineken seedings are. LaRo and Leinster had to play the Heineken final in the middle of their domestic playoffs which made it harder for them to win the domestic league. Leinster lose in the semi final, aren’t seeded in the 23/24 pool and the result is a group of death and the Stormers having to face the best team in Europe to get to the quarters instead of a genuine 9-16 ranked team.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

LaRo being in the group of death was the reason that the Stormers had to play the defending champions in a knockout match to get into the quarters, after finishing in the top 8.

In Super Rugby a team finishing in the top 8 wouldn’t have to then have to then play the defending champions in a knockout match to get into the last 8.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

The author doesn’t even seem to realise that participation in rugby is increasing globally. Or that the decline in Australia is nothing to do with the refereeing.

Rugby is losing the long-term battle: What World Rugby must learn from Australia before it's too late

We’re not as stupid as we look.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

Give them a break, they beat the defending champions to get out of the pool of death and were only knocked out by the champions by a point!

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

That’s right Dave. No surprise when they cut community funding from 15% of income to 2.4% while other codes continue to ramp up their investment.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

Hi Jez, what you’ve not mentioned there is that Australia turned its back on what made it great in the first place.

They became great because of an effective and consistent coaching system/coaching manual, which was part of an effective rugby pyramid. Sacking Dick Marks and dismantling his structures happened before these other leagues got so wealthy.

Then there was the strategy of decimating community rugby spend so that they could afford to run more pro teams and pay higher wages.

The Ireland then Italy now Canada youth development leader had a great analogy. “If you’re busy drinking wine and not making it, you’re going to run out. Then you’ll have to find your wine from some other source and not your own vineyard. That’s going to cost you more and you might not even like it. And when you’re finished drinking it you’re left with no wine.”

Australia needs to produce more and better players and coaches as it’s top priority. That means better, properly funded systems – and Horne and Nuciafora know how to do this. Compromising on this doesn’t work so if pro spend needs to come down through paying fewer players and/or reduced wages it needs to come down.

Australia can’t control the wealth of other leagues, but it can control what it does through its pyramid. Players will inevitably be lost, but there will also be better players overall and some will stay. RA can also be smarter on links with rich foreign clubs.

BTW I’m not disagreeing with what you wrote and I know you agree with some or most of this. Just painting a fuller picture as I see it.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

I can live with that!

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

Rugby Australia followed Warburton’s strategy of neglecting the grassroots and pouring money into the elite game from Eddie’s first tenure onwards. It’s not worked out very well.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

Didn’t they get a good profit in 2022?

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

It was three last year, and this year the Stormers were very unlucky after a good pool phase to get the defending champions of the last two years. Also don’t forget that not being in the kiwi pool helped them and they were still only getting two into the quarters.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

Exactly. I want to know their constructive proposals and the names behind the letter.

Any people bigging up Hamish’s role in the Cadbury and Stan deals but de-emphasising his role in the disasters don’t sound like the sort of people I’d want running the game. Especially when Herbert and Waugh have made sensible decisions like bringing in Horne, Nuciafora and Schmidt.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

Mind you, based on this year’s results, four of the five kiwi teams will be pocketing the megabucks. Meanwhile three of the four South African teams will be watching on TV. Looks like we’ve bluffed you with a pair of deuces.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

It’s also at the start of the new world cup cycle when we’re at our weakest.

'I'm a big fan': Kiss throws weight behind Club World Cup as Europe and Super Rugby agree to new tournament

Sevens has moved on a long way since the amateur days. It’s now a totally different type of fitness to test rugby and it’s difficult and counterproductive to move between the two.

What's the point of Sevens? It should be used to develop Test players, and would be better at it than Super Rugby

The reason I said that is how the letter emphasised his part in the Stan and Cadbury deals and de-emphasised his part in the car crashes.

Exclusive: Herbert claims 'steady progress' in rebuilding trust as RA seeks to avert more board bloodshed at AGM

Hi CUW. I think that the English deal stayed the same.

Both the quality and quantity increased at the URC with the introduction of the Saffers.

The Wrap: 'Take them to a dark place' - A quiet round grabs eyeballs for all the wrong reasons

Hi Doc, Netflix reduced the amount of original content produced by 16% in 2023 compared to 2022.

More content costs more and if the quality is lower can bring in less viewers in total. I don’t have the facts in front of me, but wouldn’t be surprised if there were more total views in Australia for S12 than S18.

The Wrap: 'Take them to a dark place' - A quiet round grabs eyeballs for all the wrong reasons

close