The Roar
The Roar

Jim Tucker

Expert

Joined October 2021

250k

Views

61

Published

225

Comments

Craggy veteran who has been writing about Test rugby since 1979 when the Wallabies' jersey had three stripes and was 100% baggy cotton.

Published

Comments

Sio is a fair shout

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

Matt Gibbon is inching towards being solid which I like
Starting is different to Pone benching all the time
Schoupp is raw but a prospect

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

And that’s a good thing..have to be belting match fit to fire. Eddie will flog a few who deserve it to get more from them. He has different gears for different players which is err coaching

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

When it comes down to it Wallabies need solid base from scrum and frontrow to have any chance of doing anything fancy

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

You should be a writer..I’m stealing that ????

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

Awful. What do touch judges do these days?

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Philip is what we all love to see…understated workhorse who never stops

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Good case.
Your Force observation played out

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Lonergan is a superb Super Rugby hooker and a big factor in multiple wins this year

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Liam Wright offers a genuine jumper in backrow. No ball carrying at all from him but you’d get that from Skelton plus Wright’s strong on ball work. Eddie will be weighing up them all

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Philip the right work ethic for No6 but operates in middle of the field not in wider channels where he’d be needed. Not quick enough. A pure lock

SRP Round 13 Talking Points: Faessler the hooker bolter, playing to Marky's strengths and Philip's late charge

Top yarn-spinning Harry. Formulating a top backrow is an artform to get all the right traits. You see quickly enough when backrows don’t have it because they limp along like three strangers straggling to your French bar or true link play is missing.
Scott Fardy was very underrated until he wasn’t and became essential.
Matt Cockbain was a superb No.6 as Minister for Defence in the 1999 Wallabies RWC-winning team…he hit ferociously, won lineouts, played a role and all with people wondering where his shoulders were.
Very enjoyable read mate

'Roam, hit, run': The bouncer Eddie must find in the Wallabies' most open position

As Eddie said, you look for things in players that you can’t coach. Suli can finish a try in the final 10m to the corner post, he is fast and he’s elite in the air with his leap and height.
Eddie striving to get more basics out of him

SRP RD 7 talking points: Tate demotion the right call, Brumby who's 'braining it' and what now for Suli and JOC?

Totally agree
One and done or…weapon

SRP RD 7 talking points: Tate demotion the right call, Brumby who's 'braining it' and what now for Suli and JOC?

It’s fair for Jones to try to see if he can get something from Vunivalu that others can’t. Bellamy did at the Storm by getting him to play angry. No one in rugby has tried that yet

SRP RD 7 talking points: Tate demotion the right call, Brumby who's 'braining it' and what now for Suli and JOC?

As Simon Poidevin famously said…it was always good to have Queenslanders on tour because it ensured some terrific banjo players (Deliverance movie reference for young ‘uns)

SRP RD 7 talking points: Tate demotion the right call, Brumby who's 'braining it' and what now for Suli and JOC?

Jones has a neck-shoulder thing. It’s causing some grief and is one of those tricky ones to come back from.
Blyth made a bit of a difference against the Crusaders with his lineout height making him a stronger target.

Super Rugby RD 6 talking points: Wallabies hint in Gordon deal, best No.9 duo since '90s, Reds' crackdown

Agreed. That convo should have happened 15 times already. Drop players who give away lots of penalties…wait…they used to do that.

Super Rugby RD 6 talking points: Wallabies hint in Gordon deal, best No.9 duo since '90s, Reds' crackdown

Gordon does look like the one who will miss out because three halfbacks will be taken to France.

Super Rugby RD 6 talking points: Wallabies hint in Gordon deal, best No.9 duo since '90s, Reds' crackdown

Well said. I think he was only trying to highlight that they wren’t hiding from it and that ‘confronting” meant absolutely making it the most important thing

Super Rugby RD 6 talking points: Wallabies hint in Gordon deal, best No.9 duo since '90s, Reds' crackdown

There are few perfect solutions. The 2013 tour outside the Tests was ruined by the ridiculous stand down of Wallabies weeks out from a Test.
A full-strength Qld Reds might well have knocked off the Lions. A severely under-strength one with Quade Cooper nearly did.
The ANZAC concept done well has merit because a rare occasion to see Aust and NZ players together has appeal. The ANZAC link is a respectful link.
Alternatively, the Pacific Island XV is being discussed as a possibility too

SRP RD 5 talking points: Brumbies white flag fizzer, Hooper vs Cane, hailing 'Harry Wreight'

Well said.

SRP RD 5 talking points: Brumbies white flag fizzer, Hooper vs Cane, hailing 'Harry Wreight'

Unfortunately, it’s not like the Test cricket where you do rotate to Bellerive Oval.
Rugby Tests are huge drivers of the game in the heartland cities of Sydney-Brisbane and should always be.
Go invisible, go Hobart and Adelaide during a big series.

SRP RD 5 talking points: Brumbies white flag fizzer, Hooper vs Cane, hailing 'Harry Wreight'

Actually, I’m all for a Test close to an Original Coopers Ale House and a giant schnitzel.
The venue was elite after the Wallabies knocked off the Boks in Adelaide last year.
Wait…maybe that was because the Pumas knocked off the ABs too while at a table of Kiwis and Argentinians.
Great night.

SRP RD 5 talking points: Brumbies white flag fizzer, Hooper vs Cane, hailing 'Harry Wreight'

True except the snowball of a Lions Test is to get kiddies interested in the fanfare and the playing of the game. Picking up five extra kids in SA compared to keeping 500 in Brisbane is a no-brainer.

SRP RD 5 talking points: Brumbies white flag fizzer, Hooper vs Cane, hailing 'Harry Wreight'

close