The Roar
The Roar

Jim Tucker

Expert

Joined October 2021

250k

Views

61

Published

225

Comments

Craggy veteran who has been writing about Test rugby since 1979 when the Wallabies' jersey had three stripes and was 100% baggy cotton.

Published

Comments

Excellent team and pocket summaries Harry. You have watched every minute of every game by this summation and been unaffected by amber or red fluids. Great work. To sparkle after 5 weeks of the tournament is the mark of a true rugby marathon man.
Doris, Botia, Keenan, McFarland etc…keep picking your own team with your own eyes not the popularity contest winners.

World Cup team of the pool stage: Irish domination, minnows surprise, one Wallaby makes the cut

Maturity his making and being in far better programs than the average Rebels squads of old

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

Australian rugby’s DNA is a link 7. Eddie did pick Sam Underhill at 7 for Eng. He was a beast tackler and jackalled. Hands average at best
One to ponder. Brad Wilkin was superb for Rebels too

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

Swinton’s hands hold him back. Nasty 6 is a job description for sure
Not sure Leota is more than bursts of good

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

Good call. He’s that bigger No.6 body everyone wants with lineout oomph.
Gotta perform on this big stage

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

Absolutely. Freshest performances in the mind always count. The Rebels seem like they finished playing a month ago.
Schoupp, Hooper, Reimer … all are great examples of the Brumbies’ excellent development system. They will kick on for 2025

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

You’re spot on. Luck or rather a good/bad blast of the whistle is more prominent in rugby than any footy code

SRP semi-final talking points: Eddie's most vexing debate could be settled if cowbells are silenced by Brumbies

That Pietsch missed try was very costly. A 14-10 lead potentially and value for a pressuring start. Instead a tumble

SRP QF talking points: The 'crushing fail' Australia must avoid, Tahs duo who can seal World Cup tickets

Fair view. Mark N could be a fine fullback but needs time in the spot

SRP QF talking points: The 'crushing fail' Australia must avoid, Tahs duo who can seal World Cup tickets

The Reds are wearing black armbands today for the late Wayne Smith which is a wonderful tribute

SRP QF talking points: The 'crushing fail' Australia must avoid, Tahs duo who can seal World Cup tickets

Just beating Kiwi sides with slightly ragged play is a problem any Aussie side would love as a problem ????

SRP QF talking points: The 'crushing fail' Australia must avoid, Tahs duo who can seal World Cup tickets

Rebels the best performed side in losses all year. Don’t yet know how to win. Brums have a gear to go to

SRP QF talking points: The 'crushing fail' Australia must avoid, Tahs duo who can seal World Cup tickets

Well said. You can see Growdo smiling now he has a worthy friend and adversary to spar with

'Sharp witted, brave, insightful': Rugby pays tribute after veteran writer Wayne Smith dies

Lovely memory. That was Smithy

'Sharp witted, brave, insightful': Rugby pays tribute after veteran writer Wayne Smith dies

Didn’t say it wasn’t a smart call. They travelled last week as well.
Perfectly shrewd move

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

I want to read another backrow think piece

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

Haha
Great source of pride for u. Enjoy.
I’m proud of James Tucker because we have the same name and we are not even related

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

Rebels only gave themselves to blame that they are in sudden death mode in Canberra. Playing great footy is different to knowing how to win.

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

Colvin,
We search for reasons why SRP is a little down market at times and miss the obvious point that Waratahs and Brums sent weakened teams to NZ earlier in season and Kiwis have done same for selected games in Aust. Poor form eroding own product

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

Wright, Kellaway, Petaia, Nawaqanitawase + Koroibete are better Test wingers at present

SRP Round 15 talking points: Winner takes all in Suva, Aussie sides look to avoid disaster, will Vunivalu repay faith?

Enjoy class in any coloured jersey

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

Lucky if he’s player 33

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

Petaia best No.13 backup
Unselfish and good passer and busts line and tackles big

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

When Perese’s keg drive returned after knee problems, his whole game lifted. Rodda and Philip will take time too

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

Long game with Tupou…the QFINAL of World Cup is 5 weeks after the start of tournament so that time is vital

SRP talking points: Eddie everywhere offers something Rennie never could, how Rodda can channel Eales

close