The Roar
The Roar

Michael Essa

Roar Guru

Joined November 2013

94.2k

Views

40

Published

1.3k

Comments

If life was a game of rugby it would be half time and although I had a few ruck marks I'd be ready to get stuck right back into the second half. I'd be looking forward to the end of match drinks mostly!

Published

Comments

Fair enough.

The season doesn’t hinge on the next game, they could lose it and still be on top of our conference, but boy would it be nice if they got up.

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

They almost lost to the lowly reds.

They look like flat track bullies to me, I think they’ll score plenty of tries and top the regular season, but they’ll be there for the taking come semi finals time by a tougher side like the Crusaders.

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

lol

Yes deserving of an internal fine i’m sure

Well spotted!

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

You may have noticed that the top 3 is made up of the top of each conference.

They are in the top 3.

In reality though at the moment the 3 best form sides in the comp are the Crusaders, Jaguares and the Waratahs. In that order.

By seasons end it will be the Waratahs, Jaguares, Crusaders, in that order.

Both the tahs and jaguares are building niclely. The Crusaders have peaked.

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

In some ways the 2018 pack is better than the 2014 one. Its more mobile and it has a much better lineout.

In other ways it is not. The 2014 group was more physical.

Similarily the 2018 backline is better than the 2014 in some ways. Naiyarovoro was ineligible to play in the finals in 2014 as he had not played enough games. He’s a trump card like we’ve never had and a thousand times better player than Alofa Alofa.

Rona has a muuch better passing game than AAC. AAC had a better breakdown game. That kind of cancels each other out. Horne was a better contact man than Clarke. But Calrke is quicker. The rest is on par because they’re excatly the same players. But this year we have a better reserve no 9 in Gordon, who could easily be the best no 9 in the country if he can improve his decision making.

So really it’s a better backline. And in some ways a better pack.

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

Hi Sam,

They were not poor against the Blues. They were good bt unlucky.

I too am impressed with the Jaguares and was going to go onto a tangenta as you have done in regards to predicting the eventual conference toppers and finalists.

So i am glad you brought it up.

I think the Lions are vulnerable with 2 byes on their horizon and indifferent form and they will relinquish the SA conference to the Jaguares by season end. I think the Jaguares are in the same form that the Waratahs are in and they in my mind look the two best sides in the competition at the moment.

I agree with you that the semi finals will be as you suggest. But the Waratahs will finsih 2nd and therefore host the Jaquares and beat them.

The Crusaders will beat the Hurricanes from 4th position and this will allow the Waratahs to host the GF in a rematch of the 2014 final at the Olympoic Stadium.

At which point they will be put to the sword by these magnificent Waratah men!

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

thanks CP,

You get me! sob of delight…

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

they won by 29 points didn’t they?

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

no we’re top 3 quality at the moment and by seasons end I can see us being no1.

Don’t care who’s right or wrong.

Just that we shouldn’t discredit the tahs as the default stance to take.

I’ve only genuinely beiieved them capaable of winning the comp once before. That was 2014,

Even in 2008/2005/2002 it was always in the back of my mind that they weren’t capable of beating the no 1 side, in all those cases the Crusaders.

This year I can see them beating anybody, as I did in 2014, and in fact I believe by seasons end the only thing that could cost them is not having a home final.

Is 2018 the new 2014 for the Waratahs?

Too much is made of the 40 -1 loss win ratio over 2 seasons.

It is a coincidence that all of the Australian teams are in a rebuilding phase/lull.

It will naturally cease to be a factor.

Five things we learned from Super Rugby Round 14

It’s funny

I wrote an article about this very thing 4 years ago.

Guess I was right despite the naysayers.

Israel Folau will become Super Rugby's greatest try scorer

thats hilarious… shane warne knew where to draw the line…. i’m going to laugh myself to sleep

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

bradman was a gentleman. Miller was not. i think you have it the wrong way around.

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

Michael holding talks about that fact all the time. They didn’t sledge. ever.

Curtly Ambrose was another one that believed sledging was not okay and never uttered a word at the opposition. When he went after Steve Waugh in the Windies, i recall richie richardson dragging him away, it was not a verbal stoush, it was because Waugh wouldn’t shut his mouth and Ambrose thought this approach was out of order, ironiclaly he chose to try and get physical, which is not okay, but i think this illustartes the windies polic on sledging. In their eyes it was not okay.

as for mcdermott, that was one side of the story, and in any case seems to be the exception not the rule..

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

his own book

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

play the game for the games sake, respect the opposition, do your best for the team, be a gracious victor/loser

pretty simple stuff, old fashioned but I’ve seen the results of deviating from this;

today we play the game to win, care nothing for the opposition, seek personal glory, carry on like a pratt when you win/ make excuses when you lose… this has sadly led us down a a path to where we are now

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

sad on many levels

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

no i recall mcgrath, and slater losing their sh## when they had to cop it.

sure their were many more

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

yes i couldn’t believe he mentioned the spirit of cricket.. the irony

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

i think you may be talking about banter.

banter is fine.

Sledging/verbal aggression should be out lawed

clever people than me need to draw up the guidleines but we can start by asking does what you say add to the enjoyment of the game or not.

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

yes it was completely unnecssary. Sledging/aggression on a cricket field is completely un-necessary.

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

an interesting comment

cheers

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

you just don’t get it

yes we had success under waugh.

Thats not the point

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

Waugh = Fight, win at all costs, sledge, cheat

in that order

bradman = play, enjoy, end of

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

The west indies did not sledge!!!

They just played.

Steve Waugh ruined cricket. Sledging is the real cheating

close