The Roar
The Roar

Noodles

Roar Rookie

Joined August 2018

0

Views

0

Published

1.7k

Comments

Mature business type who once ran about rugby pitches in various parts of NSW, Asia and the UK. Namesake is the great Neil "Noodles" Adams of Merewether Carlton and Wallabies.

Published

Comments

Noodles hasn't published any posts yet

Again, Ross makes a good argument. But he’s not yet saying who sits in those chairs. In my view the whole system has been shown up. That includes the state hierarchies. But we simply cannot trash the lot. Ideally there are excellent candidates to put up for board seats and they should announce themselves. Some might even get elected. Otherwise fans can get behind the team they follow and where they can, give certain people a good kick in the bum.

'Definition of madness': Rugby reform must start with total cleanout of RA board - and this should happen next

If Beale is a candidate then Sam Carter is a certainty.

Five things: What Beale has over other golden oldies, double pain for Brumbies as Blues expose Australia's biggest weakness

Medrano and Carter were huge. Their first half effort pulled the saders apart. White also had a very big game. Stewart is a really important piece of the force puzzle: he simply puts confidence into the tricky moments.

Beale, Rodda shine on Super Rugby return as Force smash Crusaders to keep finals hopes alive

I’d say Gordon is the choice right now. We have seen the 10s with both dominant and losing packs and Gordon is the one who comes out well with both. Noah had his chance last night to demonstrate grace under pressure and he didn’t. I don’t believe Donaldson is any more reliable at the test level.

Brumbies 'systematically taken apart by the Blues' in 'non-contest' as Larkham's men cop huge reality check

Bernie summed it up for me. Too much tackling was upright, which is a gift to powerful players. That said, canes and Blues are playing with power and cohesion.

Brumbies 'systematically taken apart by the Blues' in 'non-contest' as Larkham's men cop huge reality check

I thought the strong feature was the driving forwards play. Esp in the first half. They controlled possession and made yards. Left landers with very little opportunity.

'Like a Scud missile': World Cup reject leads rout, but Reds suffer fresh blow with Petaia's season in jeopardy

I’d be wondering about the pattern. From what I know all the people Schmidt has attracted are straight, direct and passionate. They’re all mature people who’ve had enough up and down time. All of them get very good reviews from players. None of them have any dodgy australian rugby politics. That will do me.

CONFIRMED: Wallabies land final piece of coaching puzzle as ex-Lion signs on ahead of showpiece event

We’ll find out!

Super Rugby teams week 9: Beale back for first time in 1494 days, Reds make 6 changes, Wallaby returns for Brumbies

But how many nations where the rich clubs control the game? I really hope we do not have to find out!

Scrap the Giteau Law: Rugby Australia should look to Rassie's 'Boks RWC recipe if it wants to re-join the big boys' table

Interesting point Harry. Which begs the question: what will unions do if French clubs end up crashing their livelihood? IMO fans want their national team to come first. Club owners and players might prefer other options. I’d be backing the national unions.

Scrap the Giteau Law: Rugby Australia should look to Rassie's 'Boks RWC recipe if it wants to re-join the big boys' table

Your points are good ones Harry. But you also offered in your podcast a strong negative: the effect on cohesion. WBs will likely have a young squad for a bit and not a lot of players who’ve developed closely together. Boks on the other hand have a lot of older players who’ve spent long periods together.

Scrap the Giteau Law: Rugby Australia should look to Rassie's 'Boks RWC recipe if it wants to re-join the big boys' table

Fraser was upright and his shoulder driving upward. Certainly chasing the ball, but contacted the melon instead. It’s the very action laws aim to stop. I remain flummoxed at the Drua decisions as both warranted harsh penalties.

'Not ideal': Reds star duo cop Super Rugby bans after red cards - but where's the consistency?

Rennie didn’t have an obvious 10 and was bringing on inexperienced options when cooper was unavailable. Kiss is in the same boat.

Five things: Lesson Aussie rugby can learn from Kiwis - and why next month will determine whether SR gap has closed

Makes a nice combo. I’d imagine Kellaway is up for 15, though Tom Wright is pushing hard, and we seem to have good options on the wings.

The Wrap: Crusaders' shot clock fiasco and shhh, don’t put the moz on Darby

With Foketi and Ikitau outside him, Gordon gets a lot of options and two very good readers of the game. Foketi is also very good at making ground in tight situations. The three together would give wings quite a bit more in terms of options. But I don’t know what happens if Carter isn’t kicking well?

The Wrap: Crusaders' shot clock fiasco and shhh, don’t put the moz on Darby

There were some very encouraging displays. Carter Gordon showing his resilience in contact as well as glorious pass. Foketi at the Tahs reminding us that he and Ikitau make a great WBs combo. Rebels front row. Tahs unsung Gamble and Heaven. But the Reds! What’s in their heads?

The Wrap: Crusaders' shot clock fiasco and shhh, don’t put the moz on Darby

Ref had a lot to do. I can’t recall seeing multiple deliberate knockdowns of a pass in defence by one team in a few minutes. Landers seemed to be inviting trouble. Lucky to not get a bunch of cards. But I’d say the kiwis were the ones complaining.
Rebels really need to sort their lineout and first up tacklers. Gifting opportunity to opponents. But they are fun to watch and great to see them putting a few wins together.

'Kid wonder': Lancaster, Gordon shine as Rebels take one giant step in locking in maiden Super Rugby finals berth

Great to see him have such a great comeback game. But he’s got a way to go before he’s a WBs contender. At this stage Noah seems like top choice with Carter held back by kicking.

'Last few years have been hell': Iceman 2.0 Harrison gets 'dream come true' in Tahs' stunning golden point win

Reds consistently have trouble with a firm, muscular defence. Clearly have the skills but seem stuck on trying to bully defences that won’t be bullied.

'Brain explosion': Wallaby stars sent off as Queensland left red-faced in Moana Pasifika shocker

Certainly is Peter, though I think Rennie was going there – until EJ took us back to kindy selection. This is why I think Neville is looking good for a lock spot, and Smith might get there with a bit more aggression. Valetini shows it every week nowadays and Gibbon is another.

'Brutal and violent': The two aspects Reds workhorse wants to fix to take next step towards Wallabies

That’s the test I think Bodger. The collisions. Reds didn’t cope when defences came at them consistently. Blyth will be helpful if he’s calmed down.

The Roar's Super Rugby expert tips and predictions, Round 8: Lock in the Reds, pray for the Tahs, fear the jinx

I reckon the Rebels might take another step this week and tighten up the defence, to give them a good win. Tahs, on the other hand, have a passive tackle approach that really has to change or they’ll really take a beating. If Moana come with a beefy defence the Reds will be tested again, I suspect. Canes should power over the Chiefs. In short, it’s toughening up time.

The Roar's Super Rugby expert tips and predictions, Round 8: Lock in the Reds, pray for the Tahs, fear the jinx

Marky Mark hasn’t had his head in the game this season. Work rate poor, low level of energy. I am wondering whether he’s realised that he’s opted out of the WBs and that’s now sunk in.

Super Rugby teams round 8: Tahs drop Marky Mark, Kellaway returns for Rebels, HMP replaces Lynagh

Spot on JDK. Ross is a genuine bloke, I’m sure. His points are probably in line with what many propose (though hints of the ghost of Hamster may be a bad sign). But we need to know who is on the ticket and what exactly they propose. I agree: Herbert and Waugh appear to be making sound choices, and let them go ahead on that track. We do not need another round of disruption.

COMMENT: Australian rugby is a depressing picture - the RA board must be axed and the constitution changed

He’s a man with a big heart and gives it all. Terrible for him to have this torture and we can only hope he has great support at home. I know from people who know him that his dad will be a rock. Best wishes.

'Needs to be considered': Bell out of Super Rugby season as ex-Wallaby suggests left-field positional switch

close