Like any new system it will always be hamstrung by the inequitable AFL fixture. In a normal 22 round season your proposal would be greatly affected by who you play twice. If a team was fortunate to be given a soft draw with return games against the cellar dwellers, they could get an unfair boost to their “points for”. Whilst the same obviously applies to traditional percentage it would be even more pronounced under your proposal.
Sorry, but it’s a no from me.
Why it's time to ditch percentage from the AFL ladder
Like any new system it will always be hamstrung by the inequitable AFL fixture. In a normal 22 round season your proposal would be greatly affected by who you play twice. If a team was fortunate to be given a soft draw with return games against the cellar dwellers, they could get an unfair boost to their “points for”. Whilst the same obviously applies to traditional percentage it would be even more pronounced under your proposal.
Sorry, but it’s a no from me.
Why it's time to ditch percentage from the AFL ladder