By Bruce Walkley
April 27th 2009 @ 7:03am
Related coverage
Home ground advantage – just steer clear of the graveyard
Brad Sewell of Hawthorn in action during the AFL ANZAC Day Round 05 match between the Hawthorn Hawks and the West Coast Eagles at Aurora Stadium. Slattery Images
The system under which Victorian-based clubs mostly play “home” games at either the MCG or Docklands has all but robbed those clubs of traditional home-ground advantage.
The obvious exception is Geelong, who have eight games at Kardinia Park this season and are notoriously hard to beat there.
Less obvious, but nearly as helpful, is Hawthorn’s edge at York Park in Launceston, where the Hawks have now won nine of their past 12 games – three out of three in 2006, two from four in 2007, three from four last year and one from one so far this year.
There are three more to come, of which the Hawks should win at least two, with the round 19 blockbuster against St Kilda the big question mark.
Hawthorn showed against West Coast on Saturday night that they have absorbed the most vital bit of local knowledge about York Park – you don’t try to attack via the right-hand flank when kicking to the Invermay Park end.
It’s been a known graveyard, particularly for right-footers, since Roy Cazaly was playing with local team City, and it was noticeable that Buddy Franklin made most of his leads at that northern end to the grandstand side.
In fact the teams outscored their northern end efforts two to one by kicking 12 of the game’s total 18 goals at the city end.
Two West Coast misses from the dead pocket were very costly in the final quarter, followed as they were by the fourth goals to both Jarryd Roughead and Garry Moss that virtually sealed the result.
The timely but widely expected Hawthorn win was just part of a fascinating round, with other highlights including St Kilda and Fremantle exceeding expectations with the ease of their victories over Port Adelaide and Sydney.
Could it be that the Saints are at long last going to make a serious assault on all those jokes about two premierships on the one day? If they win three of their next four I’ll jump on the running board, if not the whole bandwagon.
Essendon’s epic Anzac Day win over Collingwood, Carlton’s clinical destruction of the Bulldogs and Richmond’s restoration of a bit of faith by beating North Melbourne were other highlights, with the Demons v Crows shambles the only dampener.
A couple of the weekend’s efforts by scribes and commentators were right up there with some of the best over the years, too.
Jenny McAsey of The Australian wrote that Sydney midfielder Jarrad McVeigh revealed that club stalwart drank “some green algae” during games when teammates were downing more conventional sports-drink concoctions.
“I wouldn’t get near it,” McVeigh added unsurprisingly.
That brought to mind the fondness of a Tasmanian old-timer called Merv Mitchell, who played for North Launceston and later East Launceston, for a “pony” (four or five fluid ounces, I forget which, in the old measure) of sweet sherry during the three-quarter-time huddle.
And the tale of how a football-loving priest’s call for a swig of brandy as a rough and ready painkiller for a player with a broken arm after a game with Latrobe, also in Tasmania, couldn’t be met.
“Warne-Smith drank the last of it at half-time,” a member of the training staff said, referring to the great Ivor, who later won two Brownlow Medals playing for Melbourne.
Then we were told, as quick as a flash after the event on Sunday, that the Western Bulldogs’ Jarrad Grant was the 172nd, or some equally unbelievably numbered, player to hit the goalpost with his first kick in the VFL/AFL. Do we believe it? Who’s going to argue?
And later in the same game Dennis Cometti pithily described Carlton’s Setanta O’hAilpin as having “delusions of adequacy” after making a bumbling skill error.
The same S. O’h, back from a suspension for bashing a teammate and putting the boot into his bum during a pre-season practice game, had come under notice in the first quarter when, running into an open goal, he blazed away from 45 metres and – yes, Virginia – kicked a behind.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...
(11)
Michael C said | April 27th 2009 @ 12:43pm | Report comment
Geelong has the best set up of ANY club,
and Hawthorn has a very nice relationship with Tassie that affords a partial home ground advantage ‘advantage’ each year relative to the other Melb based clubs,
now, if only NOrth Melbourne can negotiate a suitable arrangement with the main oval in Currie……
gocats said | April 27th 2009 @ 2:20pm | Report comment
Geelong does not need any help – they are simply the best club with the best player ever- -GO Gary – you will definately win the Brownlow this year. And the cats will once again claim their rightful place at the top even if they have to play in Timbuktu
tigersforever said | April 27th 2009 @ 2:22pm | Report comment
The Tigers showed what they can do at the weekend- hang in there Terry Wallace- despite everyone writing you off you are not dead yet!
Redb said | April 27th 2009 @ 2:25pm | Report comment
tigersforever,
how important was it to have Mark Couglan back in the side? He picked up a few touches but from a motivational perspective must have given a boost.
Redb
bluebloods said | April 27th 2009 @ 2:26pm | Report comment
The wonderful and proud Carlton football club, who demolished the Bulldogs, will give the cats a run for their money for this years flag – depsite the fact as Bruce and Micheal C point out they do have the best deal of any club from the AFLt
footylover said | April 27th 2009 @ 2:28pm | Report comment
The fact that families can no longer go to their local ground to watch their local team play footy is just a futher example of what is wrong with sport now -Like most other sports the AFL is all about money and sponsors – its no longer a game for the man in the street and his family- indeed its unaffordable for them except on the telly – very sad
tigersforever said | April 27th 2009 @ 3:58pm | Report comment
You said it Redb- having Mark back was a dream come true – and when is Cousins coming back – do you know Bruce or does any oneelse know
ren said | April 27th 2009 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
it needs to be remebered that these ‘home games’ at york park and kardinia park are often at the expense of the non victorian clubs or poor pulling melbourne clubs.
im pretty confident that either freo or westcoast have travelled to york park and kardinia every year, and also the gold coast, canberra and even darwin when mathces were at all of these grounds.
on a side note it was nice to hear the doggies refuse to blame the road trips they had undertaken after their loss to wce (two trips west in the first four rounds?). they said something along the lines of freo and wce do this trip every second week… we have’t got a leg to stand on with the travel argument…
Redb said | April 28th 2009 @ 9:35am | Report comment
Not sure on Cousins, he is not playing in Sydney this week, can’t be far away though as the SCG game looked likely for his return a couple of weeks ago.
Redb
tigersforever said | April 28th 2009 @ 10:23am | Report comment
Maybe once Cousins comes back Richmond will really roar – lets hope he has an injury free period for a while. Also all those people bleating for Wallaces head should now remember how well he has handled the Mark Couglan episode- not many coaches would be prepared to wait three years for someone to get back to their best – they would have cut them years ago- good to see at least one coach still has some good old fashioned values – which he also showed when he was the only one prepared to take Cousins – lets hope he gets his reward
gocats said | April 28th 2009 @ 12:53pm | Report comment
Get real tigersforever -There is absolutely no place in todays game for old fashioned values – Wallace is holding back the tigers – and they will be losers till they lose him