Has Verbeek got it right for Indonesia?
By Ben Somerford, 18 Feb 2010 Ben Somerford is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- A-League, AFC Asian Cup, football, Pim Verbeek, Socceroos

Socceroo's coach Pim Verbeek chats with Harry Kewell during a training session at ANZ Stadium, Sydney, Thursday, June 19, 2008. The Socceroo's take on China in a World Cup qualifying match this Sunday, June 22. AAP Image/Dean Lewins
Australian boss Pim Verbeek yesterday named his squad for the ‘must-not-lose’ AFC Asian Cup qualifier against Indonesia in Brisbane on March 3, with the 25-man squad consisting of 21 local-based players along with four from abroad. So has he got it right?
The Socceroos’ qualification for next year’s Asian Cup in Qatar hinges on a result against Indonesia in a fortnight’s time. A loss could see us embarrasingly miss the continental tournament.
Make no mistake, that would be a huge blow for the status of football in Australia.
But, of course, our populous northern neighbours Indonesia are hardly world-beaters, with a current FIFA ranking of 136.
Nevertheless, a Socceroos team made up entirely of A-League players had their problems with the Indonesians just over a year ago when they could only manage a 0-0 draw in Jakarta.
With that in mind, and considering so much is at stake, along with the fact this is actually an official FIFA international date, Verbeek must’ve been tempted to call on his European stars.
But considering the time constraints of the FIFA window it was not ideal, with those players likely to arrive less than 48 hours before the game.
And a distraction like this could potentially jeopardise the first-team places at club level for some of our Socceroos, which wouldn’t be ideal going into the World Cup, with ‘game-time’ the key thing heading towards June.
Indeed, on that note, Verbeek’s squad selection is the right decision.
The four foreign-based players he’s called upon, Joshua Kennedy, Mark Milligan, Jade North and Luke Wilkshire, could all play important roles on March 3, while there’s enough strength in the rest of the squad to get the job done.
Verbeek isn’t normally the type to take a gamble, but the point is the squad he’s picked really should get the job done on home turf against a team ranked 136 in the world, especially considering they don’t even actually have to win the game.
A draw will be enough (that’s not to say that I think that they should play for a draw).
But the problems of the ‘A-League-Roos’ in the past has been their inability to retain possession and their lack of potency in attack, highlighted by a return of no goals against Indonesia and Kuwait in our first two Asian Cup matches in 2009.
In Verbeek’s latest squad he appears to have tried to address those issues, with the increasingly-impressive Wilkshire likely to control the midfield alongside seasoned Socceroo Jason Culina.
Wilkshire was the outstanding performer in an A-League dominated Australia side in Kuwait earlier this year, when the sides drew 2-2. Linking him up with Culina, who missed the Kuwait game, is a solid base.
And Verbeek has also opted to deploy his favourite attacking weapon in Asia – Japan-based bigman Kennedy.
Kennedy’s selection is slightly curious considering the J.League season kicks off the following weekend, with the big striker’s side Nagoya Grampus travelling to Gamba Osaka for a March 6 match, but he won’t need to adjust much to the relative time-zones and he is perfect for Australia’s circumstances.
I admit I don’t know much about Indonesia’s centre-halves, but I dare say, Kennedy will cause them problems. He has, after all, against some of Asia’s best despite being a fairly predictable route to goal.
On the topic of forwards, Daniel McBreen’s selection has been greeted with plenty of skepticism, but it seems Verbeek is looking for back-up to Kennedy should anything unforeseen happen to the man known as ‘Jesus’.
McBreen could easily play a similar role with Verbeek saying yesterday, “the strikers I have can do a job”. It seems Verbeek has his heart set on the familiar target-man tactic.
Down the other end, Verbeek may have been tempted to call up reliable goalkeeper Mark Schwarzer to reinforce and organise the defence, but you wouldn’t expect him to be kept terribly busy against Indonesia and Eugene Galekovic is more than capable in his absence.
Verbeek also hinted at his preferred defensive duo when quizzed about Wellington pair Jon McKain and Andrew Durante yesterday.
He responded: “Playing well together for their club can be an advantage but Simon (Colosimo) did well the whole season and Jade North can play there.”
North, who has been frozen out of action at club and international level in the last six months, gets a reprieve ahead of Urawa new boy Matt Spiranovic, while the likes of John Aloisi, Sasa Ognenovski, Joel Griffiths, Eddy Bosnar and Adrian Leijer can kiss their World Cup hopes goodbye.
Perth Glory’s Chris Coyne is another curious absentee although Verbeek commented: “I know Coyney has done everything to be part of the World Cup, so far that hasn’t happened. But there’s a few months to go. At this moment these are players are doing better than Coyney. There are no guarantees in football.”
Indeed, Verbeek and his latest Socceroos squad shouldn’t forget that final comment, because there will be no guarantees on March 3 when the Indonesians try to salvage something from a poor qualification campaign in Brisbane.
Sure, you fancy the Socceroos should get the job done, but whichever team Verbeek has picked, the job still needs to be done. Indonesia on March 3 must now be the focus.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- A-League, AFC Asian Cup, football, Pim Verbeek, Socceroos

Tifosi said | February 18th 2010 @ 4:27am | Report comment
Not much Pim could do with the squad.
If this a-league socceroos cant beat indonesia at home, then they should disband the A-league.
george said | February 18th 2010 @ 7:51am | Report comment
After the world cup this year and the boys retire that is predicted , the future is bleak .
Gibbo said | February 18th 2010 @ 7:56am | Report comment
reading through the squad sure didnt fill me with confidence…
Davstar said | February 18th 2010 @ 8:14am | Report comment
Verbeek isn’t one to take a risk so this is very un-like him. The A-league boys have failed in every chance they have got in the Green and gold however Indonesia isn’t much on an opponent we should still win this comfortably that being said we only drew against Kuwait because we have Vidosic, Whilk and Jedi the other A-league boys did pretty much nothing so im hoping Culina, Whilk and Kennedy can pull us through.
AndyRoo said | February 18th 2010 @ 9:02am | Report comment
There are enough good players in that squad to make a good first 11….. wouldn’t want a case of flu to go through the side because a lot of the back ups are a bit sus.
I don’t know why Spiranovic didn’t get a call up, is he injured? Also if ever their was a tie to call Sasha up this was the one, at home against a team where his aerial ability would really worry them.
The full back positions are a bit light on talent so I would be looking at perhaps playing Colisimo their rather than as a centre back.
whiskeymac said | February 18th 2010 @ 9:49am | Report comment
this : Chris Coyne is another curious absentee although Verbeek commented: “I know Coyney has done everything to be part of the World Cup, so far that hasn’t happened. But there’s a few months to go. At this moment these are players are doing better than Coyney. There are no guarantees in football.”
versus: North, who has been frozen out of action at club and international level in the last six months, gets a reprieve
One guarantee is Pims adoption of North. how can North be doing better than others if he isnt actually getting game time – or is he getting gametimeand it wasnt reported? I wld hope Spiranovic wld get some game time ahead of the others but maybe we are all going to have to wait until Pims gone for this happen (not a slur on Pim but rather recognition that there will be necessary rebuilding after this WC witha new coach)
markwakefield said | February 18th 2010 @ 1:44pm | Report comment
the point is that verbeek wont be here after the world cup so it has no impact on him whether we make it or not… it seems this side was picked more with the world cup in mind…
stevo said | February 18th 2010 @ 9:51am | Report comment
its good to see musialik getting a run. he has shown a lot of promise but hasnt delivered just yet but i think he would fit in well with pims style: he will rarely lose the ball, is one of the best passers in the a-league (short, long even occasionally towards the opponents goal), put a hard worker (milligan or wilkshire maybe) and you’d have a pretty good 2 in pims 4-2-3-1
Benny said | February 18th 2010 @ 11:57am | Report comment
What is wrong with a good old diamond 4-4-2? is unaustralian to be so bloody defensive minded
clayton said | February 18th 2010 @ 10:04am | Report comment
The A-league players cop a lot of stick when they don`t win. And a lot of it is unfair.
That Kuwait game – a draw away from home had headlines like “A-league socceroos” throw win away” etc – despite the fact that our central mids were euro roos, dario vidosic was also in the starting line up, and the two central defenders both had plenty of euro experience. But the media ranted about how the a-league had come up short. Did those Euro players save the team, or did they let the team down by letting the Kuwaitis back into the game?
And what about Pim`s in-game coaching. The Kuwaitis made some tactical and personnel changes at half time and came back into the match, and really came at Australia – Pim responded with … some grimaces.
You could also talk about a generational change – guys like Muscat no longer being available. Or about Pim taking a chance on kids who didn`t really pan out … Mitch Nichols is nowhere near getting another socceroos jersey at the moment. Mullen had a run. I am glad he gave the kids the opportunity, though.
Sorry, I forgot. We are supposed to blame the A-league. Agreed – if Australia loses this game, lets disband the A-league.
Davstar said | February 18th 2010 @ 11:16am | Report comment
Our European players were the ones that played well… I’m not having ago at the A-league roos but if you want to make a statement at least watch the game. Vidosic and Whilshire were the best players on the pitch in that match. Our A-league defense let us down that game badly Sterjovski was nowhere and Archie played shocking.
That being said our A-league guys wil get the job done and i they don’t then the A-league is going to come under a lot of fire and i hate to say it but i think all critics have a fair opinion when it comes to or domestic league.
Midfielder said | February 18th 2010 @ 10:27am | Report comment
Pim can only deal with the cards he has.. I think we will win and I think the side is not as bad as most are making out…
As an aside when the goldern generation return over the next two years IMO the A-League will grow at all levels rapidly…
Ben of Phnom Penh said | February 18th 2010 @ 11:22am | Report comment
It is only a FIFA friendly date so the clash with clubs is significant, particularly given the limited FIFA mandated release time. The East Asian leagues are much closer though, so I’m not surprised that Kennedy & Co. were called upon. It is also a good idea to leave Spiranovic at Uruwa as he needs to cement the position vacated by Tanaka which will be no mean feat.
In all I’m feeling good about the squad and would like to see David Williams have a run at some stage. If nothing else it will be interesting.