If you’re a supporter of the Australian, English or South African Test teams, you’d be more than likely of the opinion that in the past 12 months, no single cricketer has had more say on the outcome of individual matches than Mitchell Johnson.
A simple way to break down his impact is to run the rule over his performances from a traditional football-style ‘best-on-ground’ point of view.
Looking at each game logically, while bearing in mind the contribution all 22 players have made to the contest, allows you to award three votes for the ‘man of the match’, two for the second best player and one for the third.
Incredibly, from nine starts it would be more than reasonable to award Johnson 12 votes – or four best-on-ground efforts.
In the past 12 months, he has been the match winner in almost half of the Tests he has played and with the performances considered winding up at the end of July, he may well secure his second Sir Garfield Sobers Trophy for the ICC Cricketer of the Year along with the 2014 ICC Test Cricketer of the Year.
In investigating all Tests played since March 2013 using the 3-2-1 voting system, several facts become apparent.
Firstly, there have been some stunning efforts throughout the Test cricket world and none more so than Brendon McCullum’s knocks of 224 and 302 in back-to-back Tests during New Zealand’s 1-0 series win at home over India in February.
Secondly, the Test minnows are more than capable of holding their own, with Bangladesh a case in point.
They’re not being beaten up as you’d expect in recent times, having lost just three times from their past eight Tests, despite Sri Lankan freak Kumar Sangakkara thumping five tons, including a 319, and two 50s in four Tests against them.
Bangladesh have drawn a series against the Black Caps, beaten Zimbabwe and unearthed 22-year-old wunderkind (I’ve always wanted to write ‘wunderkind’) Mominul Haque, who has peeled off three tons and as many 50s in his seven Tests, including a superb 181 at Chittagong against NZ.
Thirdly, while individuals within a Test line-up may enjoy a ‘Golden summer’, five-day cricket requires the load to be spread across a team, particularly over an extended period, in order to sustain success.
As the number one ranked Test nation on the planet, I have awarded eight South Africans with votes across their seven matches played.
Considering the Proteas had four of their players selected in the World Test XI – Hashim Amla, AB de Villiers, Dale Steyn and Vernon Philander – you could easily surmise they have dropped away considerably in the past 12 months, particularly as only de Villiers and Amla have polled in multiple matches.
Compare their record to a resurgent Australia, a rebuilding India and a rising-fast New Zealand who have 12, nine and eleven vote-getters respectively and the reason those combinations are on the march becomes apparent.
Granted the Aussies and Kiwis have played 16 and 12 Tests each, however their contributions have come from multiple players rather than relying on dominant individuals, as is the case with England, Sri Lanka and Pakistan.
From their 15 Tests, I have awarded 12 English players votes, with Stuart Broad the standout collecting eight.
Of these dozen chief contributors, only Alastair Cook, Broad, James Anderson, Ian Bell and Ben Stokes were a part of their last Test in Sydney, which signals the crossroads the Old Enemy have found themselves at.
At the other end of the spectrum, Australia have narrowed their outlook post-Micky Arthur and picked a stable Test team with a combination of experience and youth, rather than simply having a selection policy aimed squarely at the future.
Since the four-zip drubbing in India, the Aussies have gone from a side reliant upon the batting feats of Michael Clarke and the long, dry bowling spells of Peter Siddle and Nathan Lyon to a combination bristling with contributors.
I have awarded Johnson, Clarke, Steve Smith, Ryan Harris, Lyon, Chris Rogers, Brad Haddin and David Warner votes in multiple matches, which more than underlines their ‘champion team’ ethos as opposed to a ‘team of champions’.
Anyhoo, let’s get down to brass tacks. As of today, my 2014 ICC World Test Cricketer of the Year voting is as follows with the top 20 listed.
Of the six players nominated for the award in 2013, only Sangakkara holds his place in the top dozen. *Inhaaaaale!*
M Johnson (Aus) – 12 votes from nine Tests.
K Sangakkara (SL) – 8 (7)
R Taylor (NZ) – 8 (11)
S Broad (Eng) – 8 (15)
Y Khan (Pak) – 7 (7)
R Harris (Aus) – 7 (12)
B McCullum (NZ) – 7 (12)
S Smith (Aus) – 7 (15)
D Jayawardene (SL) – 6 (5)
M Haque (Bang) – 6 (7)
C Pujara (Ind) – 6 (9)
D Warner (Aus) – 6 (14)
M Clarke (Aus) – 6 (15)
R Sharma (Ind) – 5 (6)
S Shillingford (WI) – 5 (6)
M Rahim (Bang) – 5 (8)
M Vijay (Ind) – 5 (9)
N Lyon (Aus) – 5 (13)
AB de Villiers (SA) – 4 (7)
T Southee (NZ) – 4 (10)
While I’m at it, here’s my 2014 World Test XI for the past 12 months.
The members of the side have been picked purely on the votes I have allocated for matches played, while trying to give due consideration to selecting a functional Test team and those individuals who have played less Tests in the past year than others.
The only player I have managed to maintain from the 2013 World Test XI is AB de Villiers. God help me!
David Warner (Aus), Murali Vijay (Ind), Kumar Sangakkara (SL), Ross Taylor (NZ), Brendon McCullum (NZ), AB de Villiers (SA – Wicketkeeper), Steve Smith (Aus), Mitchell Johnson (Aus), Stuart Broad (Eng), Ryan Harris (Aus), Shane Shillingford (WI), 12th Man – Mominul Haque (Bang).
Apologies to Younis Khan (Pak), Mahela Jayawardene (SL), Cheteshwar Pujara and Rohit Sharma (Ind), Michael Clarke and Nathan Lyon (Aus), Mushfiqur Rahim (Bang) and Tim Southee (NZ).
I found this whole exercise to be a brilliant way to get my head around the most outstanding cricketers of today, especially those we don’t tend to get a look at.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on my World XI. I’m sure there are many players who could easily slot in however, you must admit, it’s a pretty handy side.
What say you, Roarers?
Build your own fantasy cricket team and put it to the test with Draftstars daily fantasy competitions. Pick your match, pick your team and watch the points roll in to take out cash prizes on each match. What are you really gambling with? Set a deposit limit.
Yashasvi Jaiswal was looking comfortable at 67 off 40, until this moment when he hit the ball into his own stumps!
The Aussie made his 50 off 37 balls, for his fourth half-century of the season as his Sunrisers Hyderabad went on to beat Rajasthan…
Insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting different results. This quote is often attributed to Albert Einstein, but nobody knows if he…
This series’ twelfth and final team has a distinct West Indian flavour at the top of the order, and a domineering captain.
Mitch Marsh has been appointed as Australia's men's Twenty20 captain, set to lead a squad to the World Cup that does not include Steve…
Australia are set to turn their back on rising star Jake Fraser-McGurk’s whirlwind IPL form and drop Steve Smith in their T20 World Cup…
