Why Brendon Hartley must prove Red Bull wrong

Michael Lamonato Columnist

By Michael Lamonato, Michael Lamonato is a Roar Expert

 , ,

6 Have your say

    Brendon Hartley's F1 return gives hope to the sport's many rejects. (Photo by Clive Mason/Getty Images)

    Related coverage

    Toro Rosso’s rotating driver rotisserie keeps turning in Austin, Texas, where Brendon Hartley will make his unlikely Formula One debut at the United States Grand Prix.

    The Kiwi’s fortuitous return to Formula One comes five years since he last sat in an F1 car as a 22-year-old Mercedes reserve driver and seven years since the very rotisserie returning him to the sport first roasted his career prospects in 2010.

    Hartley stands with an almost countless number of drivers who are or have been affiliated with the Red Bull Junior Team, the young driver programme tasked with developing drivers for Red Bull Racing, and up until this weekend his name occupied a place on the more depressing but substantially longer ‘did not make it’ side of the ledger.

    But a clumsy political impasse has led to an equally clumsy solution that has had Toro Rosso make three driver changes in as many weekends, opening a door into which Hartley, out of work in 2018 after his Porsche LMP1 team announced it would be withdrawing from the World Endurance Championship imminently, has firmly placed his foot.

    First Pierre Gasly replaced Daniil Kvyat in Malaysia, the Russian dropped when Renault discovered it couldn’t easily tear up Jolyon Palmer’s watertight contract to sign Carlos Sainz.

    Gasly, however, is half a point down in the Super Formula championship, the final round of which is this weekend, ruling him out of the United States Grand Prix. Kvyat will step back in, but with Renault and Palmer suddenly agreeing to part ways pre-Austin and with Sainz already out the door, Toro Rosso found itself down a driver.

    Helmut Marko, overseer of Red Bull’s F1 activities, felt he had little choice but to return to a driver he had cast aside in the days the programme’s abundance of talent made ruthlessness effortless.

    Important here is not just the effect these driver changes will have on Toro Rosso’s ability to close the 14-point gap to fifth place; pertinent also is that Hartley’s admission into the exclusive circle of Red Bull-backed F1 graduates gives him the opportunity to change the sport’s attitude to rookie drivers.

    The concerning trend of teams looking for the next Max Verstappen-esque teenage sensation was noted here earlier this season, and it was indeed this attitude that brought Toro Rosso to the precipice of its Texas driver crisis.

    Max Verstappen of Netherlands and Red Bull Racing

    (Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool)

    The programme’s search for another silver-bullet driver has been so fervent that it had eliminated many a viable contender before they could come close to attaining F1 readiness, and the few it has left on the books are too young and inexperienced to be contenders.

    Even Gasly almost became Red Bull collateral. Despite winning the 2016 GP2 championship against the highly rated Antonio Giovinazzi, Red Bull held his 2013–16 win drought against him and labelled his title victory insufficiently dominant, choosing instead to put his career on ice in Japan.

    Had it not been for Sainz’s exit there is doubt the Frenchman would ever have received his call-up, but his impressive Malaysian debut and now likely 2018 contract have become testament to the value in returning to a long-term approach to driver development. His linear positive progression in results over the last two seasons of racing is further evidence of this.

    But if Gasly is a good example, Hartley could be a great one. Dropped from the Red Bull Junior Team halfway through 2010, Brendon has not only rebuilt a career, he’s turned what often becomes a tale of shattered dreams into a story of triumph.

    Hartley may be an F1 rookie, but he returns to the Red Bull fold as an FIA world champion – potentially a two-time champion by the end of the season – and a 24 Hours of Le Mans winner.

    Allowed to progress at his own pace, the New Zealander built himself up from his mediocre Formula Renault 3.5 results in 2010 to become a race-winner again by 2013, a factory driver with Porsche by 2014, a championship by 2015 and a Le Mans-winner this season.

    The Red Bull programme saw only limited immediate potential, but Hartley demonstrates that time can be a fantastic teacher. Needless to say, there have been few better credentialled F1 rookies.

    Austin is expected to be Hartley’s only F1 race this season, but a successful debut could convince the team to make replace Kvyat early ahead of a full 2018 season alongside Pierre Gasly.

    With Toro Rosso next season entering into a works Honda relationship that may down the track result in it leaving the energy drinks stable, it would be somehow fitting for Pierre Gasly and Brendon Hartley to lead it into the future as the two drivers Red Bull forgot along the way.

    Michael Lamonato
    Michael Lamonato

    Michael is one-third of F1 podcast Box of Neutrals, as heard weekly on ABC Grandstand Digital nationwide. Though he's been part of the F1's travelling press room since 2012, people seem more interested in the time he was sick in a kart - but don't ask about that, follow him on Twitter instead @MichaelLamonato.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (6)

    • Roar Guru

      October 20th 2017 @ 9:24am
      Bayden Westerweller said | October 20th 2017 @ 9:24am | ! Report

      I wouldn’t dismiss the prospect of Hartley contesting the balance of the season if he impresses this weekend, and the remaining WEC events don’t clash with F1. Certainly if he’s being weighed as a full-time prospect in 2018, it’d be sensible to give him as much time in the car as possible.

      Kvyat being demoted once more is a sad reality, albeit it would be more humane to make the cut now rather than keeping him on in some sort of purgatory with no future in mind. At least Verstappen can rest easy in the knowledge he’s on course to prevail at Mexico based on the previous two instances!

      This being realised would almost be cathartic for Red Bull, it’d be a roundabout vindication of its program to see one of its clan fulfil their promise following years in the wilderness, yet it would prove that outsiders are worthy of an opportunity – which Hartley has now been for some time, and allow it to reassess Toro Rosso’s purpose.

      • October 21st 2017 @ 8:41am
        Bamboo said | October 21st 2017 @ 8:41am | ! Report

        I think the fact that if Hartley was to finish 8th this weekend he would be equal with Kvyat points wise from 14 races this year speaks volumes. Obviously the engine penalty makes this very difficult, but this stat does speak volumes of Kvyats shortcomings.

        I doubt this is an isolated race for Hartley. No driver has done enough yet to be Kvyats standout replacement, but more Kvyats performances this year have been enough to justify Toro Rosso looking elsewhere.

        I think you’ll see a Hartley/Gasly line-up for the remainder of the season after this weekend. With the exception of Abu Dhabi, Hartley has LMP1 experience on all the remaining circuits for this year.

        • Columnist

          October 21st 2017 @ 8:59pm
          Michael Lamonato said | October 21st 2017 @ 8:59pm | ! Report

          “… the fact that if Hartley was to finish 8th this weekend he would be equal with Kvyat points wise from 14 races this year …”

          Statistic of the weekend.

          The LMP1 experience argument is also a good one, especially if Toro Rosso is still placing emphasis on making up ground in the constructors championship. Like you say, it’s not as though Kvyat is dong a stellar job, and Hartley has enough high-performance to lead an F1 team in his place. Should be an interesting couple of weeks.

      • Columnist

        October 21st 2017 @ 8:57pm
        Michael Lamonato said | October 21st 2017 @ 8:57pm | ! Report

        No, that possibility can’t be discounted. Toro Rosso’s line-up is now so unsettled that there the argument of disrupting stability for the championship fight holds no value, so the time may as well be used to prepare for next year.

        I think they’ll have to decide one way or another, at least internally, before dropping Kvyat for good, though, because I don’t know the Russian’s form would survive being dropped a third time.

        It’s interesting times for Toro Rosso, technically leading the way for RBR with its Honda works deal. Will Honda buy in somewhere down the line, and how might that affect the team’s decisions in the interim, especially if RBR ties up with Aston Martin further down the line? All fascinating questions we’ll just have to wait to find out.

    • October 20th 2017 @ 9:24pm
      Patrick said | October 20th 2017 @ 9:24pm | ! Report

      Helps that he is looked after by Mark Webber.

      • Columnist

        October 21st 2017 @ 8:59pm
        Michael Lamonato said | October 21st 2017 @ 8:59pm | ! Report

        Potentially — though I don’t know how much influence Mark has with Helmut Marko! But certainly Webber’s a rated talent and a world champion, so learning with him will have done Hartley no disservice.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,