Roar Rookie
Joined November 2009
1.9k
Views
2
Published
18
Comments
Published
Comments
I have a confession to make. I am a rugby tragic, to the extent that I even inserted "permission to watch Rugby, including reruns"…
Whilst it has been documented by that the Waratahs struggle to win games with Jonathon Kaplan as referee, can the same be said for…
It was either a knock on or offside – either way its a no try. If comes off Myles hand (or not), lands on Gilletts boot and is propelled forward into Inglis’s hands. That’s right he was in front of Gillett, so is offside. Knock on or offside, all day every day.
[VIDEO] Origin controversy: Inglis denied runaway try
I beg to differ Ozee316, as do the majority of those that have made a comment on this site or blog.
Should you wish to provide an alternative (that’s based on logic not emotions) let me know – it might take a few hours due to your timezone being different to mine by about 10 hours.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
That’s gold Mark, thanks for commenting.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
Cunny Funts I love the concept of everyone playing eachother once. It’s the simplest and most straightforward concept – the only reason I went with the model I did was to replicate the number of games that SANZAR had agreed upon for the new competition.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
Hi Midfielder, thanks for reading and your feedback, much appreciated mate. Before I delve into it I want to state that my article was submitted with the plan named The Angus Plan, after my son, as I believe that generation are the games future and true stakeholders. This article also appeared on my blog and the poll currently runs at 94% of respondents stating an SA team should not have been included – just go to the website on my profile to vote. 🙂
One of the best aspects of the current system is that as a supporter we get to watch our teams play teams from all three conferences and therefore test ourselves against different styles – thankfully we don’t have to watch two teams playing Jake Ball too often. It’s also important to not overlook the tremendous experience this provides our players to expand their horizons and see the world – Israel Folau has been quoted stating playing overseas is one of Rugby’s biggest drawcards – maybe this needs to be explored more.
The challenge with your question is that SA, NZRU and the ARU will each have their own short, medium and long term goals and the unfortunate thing is that they do not overlap. In Super Rugby both South Africa and New Zealand are reasonably mature from a market viewpoint, both in terms of players and supporters, with minimal competition from other football codes (except perhaps soccer in South Africa).
That leads us to the question of how to expand the game? Midfielder you are bang on in saying there are there are significant opportunities in Australia, particularly in Western Sydney (you only need to take note of the Wanderers success) as well as foreign markets most notably Japan. I question whether we have the depth for a sixth team, however perhaps it is like the Field of Dreams and if it’s built with infrastructure at the grassroots, school and NRC level the talent will develop.
Perhaps the idea of seeding a sixth franchise with players from the Pacific Islands and basing it in Penrith is something that needs to be considered, as it certainly would allow the team to quickly gain traction with the communities of Western Sydney – maybe some of their away teams could be in Samoa, Tonga and Fiji? We could also allow Australian players playing in an Asian team to be considered for Wallabies selection.
Without strong leadership from the ARU, the goal of expanding the domestic rugby will remain unfulfilled. Getting rugby on free to air, might be a good start as well.
Thats it for now, will ponder more deeply.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
That’s a good alternative 7/8s- whilst I really would love a team or two from the Pacific Islands region I can’t help but think the powers that be just don’t want to share the talent pool. NZR and the ARU wouldn’t be keen, not to mention the fact the damage they would cause – who will ever forget the contact and hits when there was a Pacific Islands team in 2004!
It would be the right thing to do though, as they have given so much to world rugby.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
Hi Darwin Stubbie, by the 13 team reference I can only take it you are referring to some of the names used for the teams. The background to this error is that I had all the teams listed, and in my haste to included location references for each team at the last moment because I thought it would better illustrate my intent. Little did I know that the Blues aren’t located in Auckland and the Crusaders must come from a region other than Canterbury – I do note an error or two with the South African teams and I must also ask for leniency in calling the use of Dunedin Highlanders instead of Otago Highlanders – that happens when its late and you have had a big day.
I must admit Sheek and soapit I did have a chuckle at the reaction. Sorry for late responses, massive day and only noticed the Roar notification on my way home.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
That’s more like it! Sometimes the simple solution is the correct one Eddard.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
You are quite correct Michael. I had all the teams listed, and in my haste omitted the wrong team – much the same with some of their names as well. I had them listed as they are now known, and at the last minute I popped in the location reference and made a couple of typos or errors – I can only trust that my Rugby brothers and sisters can look past these and gain a sense for both the issues raised and some options to improve the game structure.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
Thanks Johnno, great to know I will have good company if I am ever relegated to the doghouse! Would love to see a super club finals series with the best of Currie, ITM and NRC along with a few other ring ins. Thanks for the feedback.
Super Rugby review began with the wrong outcome in mind
I absolutely agree with your comments CKG. Jake White has done a fabulous job at the Brumbies, and if he were to be promoted my fear is that we would reduce the quality of the coaching pool with Ewen very likely to take up a coaching role overseas. Give McKenzie a shot at the Wallabies gig, he has invested infinitely more in the Australian player base for a longer period of time than his competitors.
Time for Hawker and Pulver to show the way
Well written Sofathefelloffthesofa. I do agree that a little attention to structure and the correct use of grammar makes for a more pleasant experience for the reader.
SPIRO: What went wrong for the Wallabies? Everything
Excellent advice Gatesy, as I have no doubt that all too often some of those vying for contention start to read and believe the press. How often have the Wallabies or Tahs fallen over when they start talking it up in the press, or when they get some good reviews – thanks for sharing.
I think your comments Realist are a little more playing the man than the ball – read the article again as I don’t think you will find that Gatesy was actually saying that Mogg was talking himself up although QC doesn’t mind giving himself a wrap. He may have been recommending that Mogg just focus on his business, and ignore the distraction of the media. Having said that, time to get back to work!
A message to our fringe Wallabies
Great article Clukins, with some excellent points pertaining to culture. For me once the talent has been identified, it comes down to know, like and most importantly trust -which Biltongbek has raised. It oozes through every part of a teams culture, and your desire to trust in the man inside you to do their job. Great post, and bring on 2014 as something special is starting to happen for the Tahs.
Palu hasn’t been at his barnstorming best for a couple of years now, and spends more time in the sick bay than on the field – let’s hope for the Tahs sake he remains injury free and gets back to where he was when all the talk was of him being the human wrecking ball. I would have put money on it that he was on his way to Japan, oh well.
Waratahs need to find a new team culture
I must admit that I was very disappointed when KB signed for the Rebels, as my personal view was that the Waratahs and NSW Rugby had made a considerable investment in him from his early days at Joeys only for him to move to Melbourne when that investment had started to come good.
I don’t feel that I can accurately comment on the challenges he faces, however do feel quite strongly that it’s in the best interest of organisations and teams to embrace a no dickheads policy – taken another way that’s work with those you know, like and trust. Trust being the key, as KB needs to put in the time to earn that back.
Kurtley Beale: a wrong to be righted
Add to that focus, intent and desire to attack the bomb\kick and it makes for a pretty great combination.
SPIRO: Happier days are here again for the Waratahs
What a game it was – an incredible contrast of styles and a victory for rugby with the victors actually getting over the line for two tries against a team that was trying to do anything but.
SPIRO: Happier days are here again for the Waratahs
Don’t worry he wasn’t alone. Gus Gould was death riding the blues up until about 60 minute mark, perhaps hoping his calls would come true.
[VIDEO] Origin controversy: Inglis denied runaway try