The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

The best modern-day cricketer is mostly ignored

SamStoffelen new author
Roar Rookie
7th January, 2012
Advertisement
Is Kallis better than Tendulkar? AAP Image/Andrew Brownbill
SamStoffelen new author
Roar Rookie
7th January, 2012
114
7046 Reads

The Sydney Cricket Ground gave itself every opportunity to write itself into the history books, with the 100th Test at the iconic venue playing host to a man chasing an elusive milestone.

In both innings, Sachin Tendulkar came to the crease with the match in a precarious situation; the scene was set for the Little Master, the cricketer who stares adversity in the eye.

However not for the first time this summer, Tendulkar had a touch of the Michael Slaters about him and was unable to capitalise on the platform he had built for himself. While Tendulkar had that platform to build, his Indian teammates were stuck figuring how to piece together their foundations.

Australia so far has not been a sanctuary for the flat-track bullies who in the past have found themselves at home down under.

Meanwhile, in a land far far away, Jacques Kallis, free from the burden of expectation, was chalking up his second double century, this time against Sri Lanka.

Kallis was brought to my attention by the Channel 9 commentary team during the coverage of the second test in Sydney. When discussing who the best modern-day cricketer was, they gave a nice plug to Ricky Ponting, Tendulkar and Brian Lara, with Mark Taylor only briefly mentioning Kallis at the close of the conversation.

Unjust is the first word that springs to mind, because surely it’s Jacques Kallis who is the finest modern-day cricketer.

Statistically, Kallis has the wood over Tendulkar in many facets of the game. In 150 tests, Kallis averages 57.02 with the bat, compared with Tendulkar’s 186 Tests for an average of 56.03. This, of course, is a fairly raw statistic, but below are some more detailed numbers that may be illuminating.

Advertisement

Kallis’ batting averages by opposition
72.05 versus India
66 versus Pakistan
73 versus West Indies
67.90 versus New Zealand
40 versus Australia
45 versus England
Total against these teams: 60

Tendulkar’s batting averages by opposition
42 against South Africa
42 against Pakistan
55 versus West Indies
49 versus New Zealand
60 versus Australia
56 versus England
Total against these teams: 50.6

Tendulkar has scored 51 test centuries, 33 of which have come on flat subcontinent wickets. Kallis has scored 22 of his 41 Test centuries in South Africa.

South African wickets give a lot more assistance to bowlers with swing evident, and tall quicks of the past have found decks that produce good bounce and carry. Batting in South Africa is traditionally a lot more difficult than in India.

Kallis’ stats with the ball speak for themselves. 272 wickets, an average of 30, with five five-wicket hauls.

By no means am I downplaying the magnitude of the success reached by Tendulkar. In fact, I’ve developed a better understanding and level of respect for him after visiting India late last year.

It was while walking through the busy bazaars of Jaipur that I began to appreciate Tendulkar’s impact on the people of India.

Advertisement

I was that perfect sales pitch. A young white male walking into a store meant local people who were watching felt the need to shop there also. After being ushered in by what seemed like the entire population of Jaipur, I was sat down in front of a small television with one of those ancient aerial devices.

The reception was poor, but you could easily make out that it was India against England. Before I could even get my bearings, I had offers of chai tea and food literally in my face. Tendulkar was interviewed during the game, and store owners left customers just to hear what he had to say.

The Little Master wasn’t even playing, yet he demanded the attention of these people and no doubt millions of others. I contemplated mentioning how I believed Jacques Kallis was the star of the modern game, however I’m not sure I would have kept my goodwill intact.

Tendulkar is a god in India. However, if Kallis were Indian, he would certainly be nipping at heals of Vishnu, Gandhi and Sachin.

For years Kallis has shouldered a higher workload than most cricketers of the modern era. His reputation precedes him, not only is he recognised as a distinguished batman, but as a feared bowler and handy slip fielder.

There is nothing flamboyant about Kallis. He is an elegant, textbook cricketer with a front-foot drive that has been the envy of many young batsmen over his career. His array of strokes incorporates immaculate precision with scintillating power derived from his big follow-through.

I had the pleasure of watching Kallis at his finest against India in 2010, when he notched his maiden Test double-century in one of the finest innings I have witnessed. Kallis dispatched the ball to all ends of the park, from clipping the ball off his pads for one of five sixes, to slashing a square cut to the boundary.

Advertisement

If I had to find something to disrespect Kallis, the only thing I could say is that hair transplants are better left to Doug Bollinger. Apart from that, Jacques Kallis has the honour of being my nomination for greatest cricketer of the modern era.

close