Roar Pro
Joined September 2011
29.2k
Views
26
Published
84
Comments
Pass and Move is a football blog dedicated to tactical analysis with a special emphasis on the Socceroos and the A-League
Published
Comments
There are multiple prisms through which to perceive this match; a 'relegation' scrap for one, a grudge match between former colleagues (on the pitch…
It is the 22nd of October. Mehmet Durakovic and his Melbourne Victory squad welcome derby rivals Melbourne Heart to Etihad Stadium. The home team…
Unbelievable. Brisbane produced a virtousic performance with a display of football that was at turns scintillating, exhilarating and utterly crushing. Brisbane's raw speed of…
Saturday's Melbourne Derby was an open and exciting affair, as well as an entertaining spectacle thanks to the fantastic atmosphere created by the Blue…
The majority of this Melbourne Heart vs Perth Glory game was largley disjointed. Neither side was able to establish a rhythm, and the first…
Saturday's match between the Sky Blues and the Roar was initially a close fought contest. Sydney FC coach Vitezslav Lavicka altered his tactics and…
This was a taut, tense and heated affair between the two clubs with arguably the most vitriolic rivalry in the A-League; the Reds and…
This was a match between two clubs with broadly similar systems; 4-2-3-1's, but vastly different interpretations. Gold Coast and Wellington had spells of dominance,…
Last night, Australia beat Oman in the World Cup Qualifier, with the encounter significant as it was the first competitive match for Australia in…
Brisbane Roar produced an exciting display of attacking football in their defeat of the Central Coast Mariners, based around rapid passing, positional interchange and…
This was an electric and energetic affair between two clubs who were devoted to committing players forward in the attack. Newcastle started the brightest,…
Last night's City Derby between Melbourne Victory and Sydney FC was a fitting spectacle for the A-League debuts of Harry Kewell and Brett Emerton.…
Tonight’s city derby was a scrappy and aggressive end-to-end affair. Both sides eschewed any semblance of build-up play in favour of exchanging attacks down…
Where to begin? Perth must hate the A-League; optimistic pre-seasons coupled with limp performances have become the norm for the club on the shores…
Wellington are another club to have undergone an off-season meltdown (in contrast to Newcastle, this occurred in the boardroom, not the dugout). Foundation owner…
Well, what else could possibly go wrong? Even before the shocking events of the past week - namely the surprise sacking of manager Branko…
The perennial bridesmaids to the capital clubs brides, the Mariners have been Grand Final losers to Newcastle, Sydney and now Brisbane. Long cast as…
Storm clouds obscure the normally searing sunshine of Skilled Park. The established spine of the playing squad has been ripped out and scattered to…
A third of the way into last season, Rini Coolen was being hailed as one of the best managers to ever grace Australian shores.…
Last season, Ange Postecoglou redefined Australian football. In doing so, he led Brisbane Roar to an impressive Premiership/Championship Double, while going 28-games unbeaten. At…
Yeah you’re probably right in that all players should be given time to settle in
Brett Emerton more effective as a fullback?
@ j binnie
I’m not too sure of his positional history, though I am under the impression his debut for Blackburn, where he scored, was at right midfield. He apparently did put in shifts at right back in the middle of career there, but most of the time he was stationed at wide midfield.
Technically speaking, the difference between a fullback and a wingback does not revolve around attacking intent, rather on the formation the team is using. A ‘fullback’ can be described as a wingback when there is no winger or wide midfielder ahead of him, most commonly in an old-style 3-5-2 or 3-4-3; they become literally half a fullback and half a winger and are asked to patrol the whole flank by themselves.
For instance, Maicon, when played on the right side of a back-4, can be termed a fullback. Under Gasperini, when he was asked to cover the entire right flank with no wide player ahead of him, can be termed a wingback.
Brett Emerton more effective as a fullback?
That ignores how pivotal the fullback position has become. If Emerton were to become a constant attacking threat from fullback, that would be a preferable alternative to him being marked out of the game and unable to launch his quality crosses at right wing.
Brett Emerton more effective as a fullback?
@Kasey
point taken, Classico it is. you need a bit of latin flavour
Brett Emerton more effective as a fullback?
I think I’ve fixed the problem, changing comment interface to a pop-up window rather than embedded below the text. Click on post a comment below an article you’ve viewed on a separate web page, a window should pop-up where you can type. You can choose to comment anonymously or leave a name/url, which would be preferable.
Newcastle Jets 2011-12 season preview
I’ll definitely look into that; have you tried commenting under the Name/URL or anonymous option?
Newcastle Jets 2011-12 season preview
For preview of Melbourne Victory and Sydney FC, visit passandmovetactics.blogspot.com
Newcastle Jets 2011-12 season preview
For match analysis, visit passandmovetactics.blogspot.com
Newcastle Jets 2011-12 season preview
My knowledge of the initial seasons of the a-league is thin, but the point I was trying to make was that the spine of the roar team, having played one full competitive season and 2pre-seasons won’t be hampered by a lack of familiarity, which was noticeable in the first few games last year
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
@cliff
I actually expect brisbane to be effective from the off. Last year was the first time brisbane played in their short passing style, so they were still coming to grips with it. This year, the established spine, theo, smith, franjic, paaratlu, murdocca, nichols and broich have been playing together for a year now.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
Attacking fullbacks are the best fantasy picks. Fantasy football is fixated on goals and still carries the antiquated defence, midfield and forward division. Rose, cassio, marrone, behich, franjic, traore should all come up trumps
Central Coast Mariners 2011-12 season preview
Well time will time with danning. I must say, if it were any other coach that signed him, I would have written him off as well.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
Right again TomC, I’ve neglected him. If he is as good a midfielder as they say, coolen will have 3 superb passing midfielders in his squad; levchenko, usucar and caracalla. That gives coolen the option of deploying all 3 in a fluid midfield trio, with van dijk and 2 wingers. But I think the style of play adelaide used early last season will form coolen’s preferred template.
Adelaide United 2011-12 season preview
Yes you’re right about that, arnold prefers to pack the midfield with bodies, that’s a common trend in europe. In the late 90’s that worked, because every club was focussed on deploying a classic no 10 paired with a destroyer. But now, the most dangerous players start wide on the flanks and cut-in.
Central Coast Mariners 2011-12 season preview
You’re probably right about that. Perez, in my opinion is huge loss, even though he was involved in only half of central coast’s campaign. Amini is a similar player, but not as…battle hardened? Perez’s job in nullifying paaratalu during the semi-final, in addition to his trequartista role, was magnificent.
Central Coast Mariners 2011-12 season preview
Thanks a bunch fussball, your support is invaluable.
The bread and butter of what i’m trying to do is match analysis, similar to what michael cox does in zonal making for the euro leagues. Because of restrictions on formatting and pictures, i’m not able to submit match analysis on the roar, so if you’d like to see these, check out passandmovetactics.blogspot.com
Central Coast Mariners 2011-12 season preview
Well time will tell with Williams. I can just already see Fred making a slide rule pass through the opposition centre back and fullback, Williams running onto it at full pace, maybe a 1-2 with Terra before bulging the net with a terrific shot.
I agree with Stevo, Heart will definitely be in the mix for the finals. If everything clicks into gear in an attacking sense, in my reckoning only Brisbane, Adelaide, Victory and maybe Sydney have a more potent forward line.
Melbourne Heart 2011-12 season preview
thanks for the kudos TomC
I was assuming not so much that a fantastic goal scorer will spontaneously emerge or be signed, just that brisbane’s play will continually create scoring chances by dragging defences out of shape. If you look at it that way, the finisher isn’t as important as the process of creating the chances. Its one of the reasons pure poachers have fallen out of fashion at the highest level (Eg. Michael Owen, Robbie Fowler), in favour of forwards who embody multiple attributes and contribute to the overall play of the team (Eg. Drogba, Villa, Rooney, Suarez)
You do make a good point about players vs system; even at a club like brisbane, where the system is paramount, its obvious and self-evident that better players are more able to carry out that system than inferior players. I assume you’re alluding to the departures of McKay and co? I suppose its along the lines of comparing Barcelona, who play tiki-taka with the best players in the world, and Blackpool/Swansea who tried/are trying to, with players who aren’t as good.
Victory were the only club to beat brisbane last year, but it wasn’t through a short-passing game of their own as Heart tried and failed, it was through pressing and ruthless counter-attacking. Keep in mind it only worked early in the season, when the Brisbane players were still coming to grips with Ange’s style of play. I’d argue Central Coast were better at the counter-attack than Victory, and they still got beat.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
I guess it’s a case of leave it to Ange when it comes to Broich in midfield – he’s the one that sees him train week in, week out, so we’ll have to trust his judgement.
That’s very interesting, do you still keep in touch with him? i’ve never been involved in junior football, but isn’t it a common thing for the best young technical/physical players to be used up front, as they’re the best at getting goals? Then when they progress through the age groups, they find their best positions.
On the best way to play Brisbane: It’s going to depend on how confident managers are with their players. Sitting deep in two banks of four and restricting space between the lines is probably the most obvious and defensive way, but it’s clear from last year that maintaining a perfect defence for the full duration of a game against them is near impossible. I can’t quite remember how that Victory game went, but just ask Central Coast; 15 mins to go in a grand final, and Brisbane find a way to pass their way through 11 men behind the ball.
I think Heart were unique last year, in the sense that they were the only club to try to take them on at their own game; it’s just that they weren’t as good.
Pressing Brisbane for the full 90 requires physical fitness and concentration. As you said, pressing Paartalu is key, but the main thing is to cut off passes from Theoklitos to his defence, and force them to punt it long. Prevent their build-up play, and be ruthless when you spring them. I think this is the way Coolen is going to go; his 5 options for the front 4 are all pacy, with an eye for goal.
On rotating (on pitch not within the squad) the midfield; it’s the logical solution if Paartalu is pressed intensely. Mouinho likes to do it in his midfield trio with Pepe and Xabi Alonso. So conventionally, Pepe is used behind Xabi to provide a shield in front of the back-4. But if Xabi is getting out-muscled, Mourinho will push Pepe in front of him, switching the direct opponents, leaving Xabi free to spray passes. I’m sure it’s something Ange has considered.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
@ Rellum
Thanks for the comment man
I expect big things from Heart this season, if Fred and Terra can fully deliver on their potential.
For match reports check out passandmovetactics.blogspot.com
Melbourne Heart 2011-12 season preview
@TomC
I agree about Colosimo, he’s a great defender. If i were van’t Schip, I would never have got rid of Beauchamp either; what’s wrong with Colosimo/Beauchamp at the back, and Thompson holding?
But, like you point out, van’t Schip prescribes to the Dutch school of thought; best way to defend is to hold onto the ball. The thinking is, if we have the ball, how can they score?
I think Terra, if he’s injury-free, will be very dangerous. David Williams is too underrated, I expect quite a few goals from right wing.
Melbourne Heart 2011-12 season preview
@TomC
Good to see you again man, thanks for the comment
My tip on Danning going the way of Barbarouses is pretty risky. I’ll admit it’s based on the fact that both are/were a) fast, b) right wingers, c)hyped up early and d)not able to fulfill that hype and on the outer at their former clubs. I just think he’s an ideal Postecoglou signing that way.
On the need for goal scorers; well remember last season, their top striker, Reinaldo, just up and left. Solorzano slotted in and Brisbane resumed banging in the goals. Henrique was barely involved for the first half of the season due to that arm break; he recovered, slotted in perfectly. Luke DeVere left for Korea about the same time Henrique returned; Susak slotted in. In a team where the system is paramount, instead of a handful of star players, personnel should be able to be rotated with relative ease. That’s the advantage of relying a system, as its about the cumulative effect each player exerts, rather than individual brilliance.
Yeah I’m also tipping Brisbane and Adelaide. But I don’t see why people think Brisbane can’t be dominant again. They were dominant in 2010-11 because no other club could deal with their short-passing. It’s gonna be up to rival clubs to catch up.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
@TheMagnificent11
Thanks a bunch for your support mate. The bread and butter of what I write are match reports, which include tactical diagrams – I’m not able to submit them on the Roar because they don’t accept pictures, so it’s probably better you do read them on my blog.
The thing with Broich potentially replacing McKay is that they’re different players with different attributes. Broich prefers to take on his fullback by either cutting-in or going around. When McKay plays at left-midfield for Australia, he just drifts central and plays his regular game which is based around three facets; quick/intelligent movement, rapid short passing and positional interchange. Using Thomas in central midfield would not be a straight swap.
Brisbane Roar 2011-12 season preview
yes well jonathan wilson is another who has suggested it, but I think Arsene Wenger was one of the first premier league managers to legitimise the idea with Ashley Cole
Brett Emerton more effective as a fullback?