The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

What do we mean by "the best"?

Winx at Moonee Valley.(AAP Image/Joe Castro)
Roar Guru
16th March, 2018
2

When Our Sir Vancelot became the first pacer to win three Interdominion Pacing Championships, his feat was compared to Kingston Town’s achievement of winning three consecutive Cox Plates.

Considering this alongside his overall record, it would have been reasonable to claim that Our Sir Vancelot was the best Australasian pacer of all-time.

Except he wasn’t. In fact, we know he wasn’t.

Just a few months earlier, Our Sir Vancelot raced in one of harness racing’s signature events, the Miracle Mile, and was utterly humiliated by Christian Cullen. A week later, Our Sir Vancelot was on the end of another hiding from the mighty Kiwi, although he managed to trim the margin to fourteen metres, down from twenty-four the previous week.

Serendipitous.

This is not quite the case with the queen of the thoroughbred world: Winx.

Winx, of course, is one of the greats of the Australian turf, and the best galloper in the world. But what do we mean when we say “the best”?

Do we measure by the sheer accumulation of wins?

Advertisement

The most Group Ones?

How do we assess the calibre of opposition, and is that even relevant? Has Winx been sheltered from more difficult assignments, merely to keep her winning streak going?

A common critique of Winx is that the quality of horses she has been facing isn’t particularly high. I find this to be a weak criticism, given that she has beaten 53 individual Group One winners. There are some critiques that have more weight, however.

These are directed more at Winx’s connections, rather than the mare herself, who has no say over where she races.

It seems a shame that Winx has not proven herself on the international stage. Few people will believe that a horse of her ability continued to run in races like the Chipping Norton Stakes when she should be taking on the world’s best milers.

Winx will never be tested in the helter-skelter of a Caulfield or Melbourne Cup. A golden opportunity was missed by not running Winx in the 2015 Japan Cup.

We can marvel at Winx’s three Cox Plate victories, and revel in her greatness; but can we say she had a “Christian Cullen moment,” when she took on an undisputed champion and destroyed him?

Advertisement
close